• Home
  • >
  • Blogs
  • >
  • Tribunal Victory Over £15k VAT Invoice Dispute

Tribunal Victory Over £15k VAT Invoice Dispute

Published by Prerana
Published Date: May 11, 2024

A construction company based in London, Fount Construction Limited, recently won a significant legal battle against HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) over a dispute related to a VAT invoice. The case was focused on determining whether the information on the invoices was sufficient and sheds light on important considerations for businesses that need to comply with the VAT regulations.

What Were the Key Issues in the Dispute?

In the centre of the dispute were three invoices issued by Landcore Limited, a building contractor, to Fount Construction Limited. The total amount of these invoices was £15,218.59 in VAT. HMRC claimed that the invoices did not meet the regulatory requirements because they lacked detailed descriptions of the building work provided.

Invoice dispute

The invoices only stated, “building works at the above”, which HMRC deemed insufficient information. HMRC argued the information was incomplete as they did not meet the requirements set out in regulation 14(1), Paragraphs (g) and (h) of the Value Added Tax Regulations 1995. As a result, HMRC rejected Fount’s VAT claims.

On the other hand, Fount’s representative argued that invoices do not need to be overly detailed to be considered valid. They pointed out that it is common in the construction industry to have simple descriptions on the invoices.

What was the Tribunal’s Decision?

The tribunal made a decision after considering the arguments of both Fount Construction Limited and HMRC. Ultimately, they ruled in favour of Fount Construction Limited. They acknowledge the importance of VAT verification purposes. However, they emphasised that providing exhaustive details on invoices was not necessary for it to be valid.

Instead, a brief description of the services, along with additional identifying information such as the site name or date of work, was sufficient to meet the regulatory standards. Also, the tribunal judge added claiming invoices are deemed as a gateway to enquiries by HMRC. The tax authority can reject VAT refund claims after additional sufficient information is not provided by the appellant. This ruling highlights the need for a balanced approach to information requirements, ensuring compliance without placing unnecessary burdens on businesses.


The recent victory of Fount Construction Limited in their VAT invoice dispute with HMRC has highlighted the challenges businesses face when navigating VAT regulations. The tribunal's decision clarified that invoices must contain sufficient information for tax verification, but they do not need to be overly complicated.

This ruling can serve as an important precedent for businesses dealing with similar issues, emphasising the significance of understanding and navigating VAT regulations efficiently. As companies continue to navigate the complexities of taxation, making informed decisions and taking professional VAT advice is crucial in safeguarding their financial interests.

Our Complete Guides
Related Posts

Trust UK Property Accountants to Optimise Returns and Minimise Hassles!

Reach Out to Us Today and Let's Shape
Your Success Together!

Success message!
Warning message!
Error message!