
10/7/2026
Buying the Freehold Together: What Collective Enfranchisement Really Costs
Buying the Freehold Together: What Collective Enfranchisement Really Costs Buying the Freehold Together: What Collective Enfranchisement Really Costs Background: The Leaseholders Who Bought Their Own Freehold Who Really Owns the Freehold, the Company or You? The Financial Picture The Part That Catches People Out: Extending Your Own Leases If the Company Holds As Your Nominee If the Company Owns the Freehold in Its Own Right The Stamp Duty Land Tax Position On the Initial Acquisition of Freehold Land Subsequent Extensions S Ltd: Where It Ended Up How Earlier Advice Would Have Changed the Outcome The Better Approach for S Ltd The Result of the New Approach Putting It Right, And What Every Enfranchisement Company Should Check Conclusion When a block of leaseholders buys its own freehold, the day usually ends in celebration. At a London development, 62 leaseholders came together, bought the freehold for £760,000, and paid no Stamp Duty Land Tax. The celebration was early. A few years later they extended their own leases to 999 years at a peppercorn rent, and that step created a corporation tax charge on a transaction where not a penny changed hands. It did not have to happen. The tax followed from a decision made at the very start, before the freehold was bought, and from paperwork that was never quite finished. Here is what happened, and what every block should check before it does the same. The block is a South London development of 104 units: 80 leasehold flats, 18 shared ownership homes held by a housing association, and 6 commercial units. The flats were sold on 125-year leases from 1983. In 2016, the developer offered the flat owners the freehold. The price was £760,000, a figure held down by a service charge shortfall the freeholder had to carry, because the commercial units did not contribute to residential costs. 62 of the 80 flat owners took part. What they wanted was simple: To own the freehold of their own building To extend their leases to 999 years and be rid of the ground rent To control how the estate is run They set up a company , S Ltd, to hold the freehold, funded the purchase between themselves, completed in 2018, and extended their leases in 2023. This question decides almost everything that follows, and it gets the least attention on the day. First, the practical reason a company appears at all. No more than four people can hold the legal title to a piece of land: a transfer to more than four takes effect in favour of the first four named, who hold it for everyone else ( Law of Property Act 1925, section 34 ). 62 buyers cannot all go on the title, so they buy through a single vehicle, almost always a company. That company can hold the freehold in one of two ways, and the difference is the whole game. Point Company as your nominee (bare trustee) Company as owner in its own right Who really owns the freehold The leaseholders The company Tax on the freehold's income and gains Falls on the leaseholders Falls on the company Extending your own lease Treated as your own affair between the leaseholders A disposal by the company The evidence needed A declaration of trust Shares and the company's own accounts Under section 60 TCGA 1992 , where the company acts as nominee, or bare trustee , the leaseholders are the true owners, and the company simply holds the title for them. For tax, the company's actions are treated as theirs. Where the company owns the freehold in its own right, the company is the taxpayer and the leaseholders own shares in it. Two things decide whether the company held the freehold as a nominee or as the beneficial owner in its own right: How the freehold was acquired The paperwork that records who owns it A statutory collective enfranchisement is taken through a nominee purchaser, so it points towards the company holding as nominee. A declaration of trust, naming the leaseholders as the true owners, puts it beyond doubt. Where there is no declaration of trust, and the company simply takes the title in its own name and issues shares, the company owns the freehold in its own right. At S Ltd there was no declaration of trust, so the company was the owner. That is where the tax problem started. Particulars Amount (£) Freehold price paid, 2018 £760,000 Leaseholders taking part 62 of 80 Loans to the company 62, interest-free Value of the 999-year leases granted, 2023 £625,000 Value of the reversion kept afterwards £375,000 Chargeable gain, if the company owns the freehold £150,000 The calculations are covered in the later section. Granting the 999-year leases felt free. Peppercorn rent, no premium, no cash in. For tax, it was not free at all. Two points do the damage. First, a lease extension is in law a surrender of the old lease and the grant of a new one, so there is a disposal even when no money changes hands. Second, because the leases were granted for a peppercorn and not at arm's length, the tax is worked out as if market value had been paid ( section 17 TCGA 1992, CG14540 ). Who bears that charge depends entirely on the capacity question above. The company holds the freehold for the leaseholders, so for tax purposes each leaseholder is treated as extending the lease of their own flat ( section 60 TCGA 1992 ). Granting a lease to yourself is not a disposal to anyone else, so the company does not incur corporation tax. It is not tax-free for the leaseholders, though. Take John, extending his own lease. John's Own Share Falls Away - You cannot make a taxable disposal to yourself, so John has nothing to report on his own slice of the freehold. His Fellow Leaseholders May Have a Gain - HMRC's view is that each participant owns a share of the reversion to every flat, not only their own. On that view, when John extends, each other participant gives up their small share of the reversion to John's flat in return for a share of the extension's value. Because the lease is granted for a peppercorn and not at arm's length, market value applies, so each makes a small part disposal and any gain is chargeable. Private residence relief does not help them, because John's flat is not their home. The sums are usually modest and often within the annual exempt amount, but every flat that extends repeats the exercise. This is HMRC's position, not settled law. There is no case on it, and some argue each participant owns only their own flat's reversion, so an extension has no tax effect for anyone. The personal position needs advice before extending the leases. Extra Statutory Concession D39 sits alongside this. Where an extension is granted on arm's length terms and the tenant takes no cash out, D39 lets the surrender of the old lease and the grant of the new one be ignored, so the tenant has no capital gains disposal of their own lease ( CG71240 ). It does not remove the charge on the other participants above, and because it requires arm's-length terms, it does not apply to a nil-premium peppercorn extension. This is what happened at S Ltd, and it is where the bill appears. Granting the 999-year leases is a part disposal of the company's freehold ( CG70960 ). Market value stands in for the peppercorn, so the company is treated as receiving £625,000 for the leases it granted. The cost of the freehold is then split between what was given away and what was kept, using the part disposal formula in section 42 TCGA 1992, cost multiplied by A divided by (A plus B), where A is the value given away and B the value kept ( CG12731 ): Cost of the freehold = £760,000 A, the leases granted = £625,000 B, the reversion kept = £375,000 Cost set against the disposal = £760,000 times 625,000 divided by 1,000,000 = £475,000 Chargeable Gain = £625,000 - £475,000 = £150,000 The company pays corporation tax on that gain at the main rate of 25%, about £37,500 ( marginal relief guidance ). Marginal relief, which can soften the rate on profits between £50,000 and £250,000, is often unavailable to a freehold company of this kind, because a close company that mainly holds property let to its own members can be a close investment holding company ( section 18N CTA 2010 ). The company has no cash to pay the bill, so the leaseholders fund it, and taking any surplus back out later is a further taxable event. Buying a freehold is a stamp duty land tax event. You must send a return to HMRC, and pay any tax due, within 14 days of completion, with penalties and interest if you miss it. A freehold made up of six or more flats, together with commercial units, is charged at the non-residential rates, so on the £760,000 paid for this block the tax would ordinarily be about £27,500, payable within 14 days. Collective enfranchisement changes that. Section 74 of the Finance Act 2003 sets the rate by dividing the price by the number of participating flats: £760,000 across 62 flats is £12,258 each, which is below the starting threshold of £40,000, so the rate is 0% and the tax is nil. The relief is not automatic, though. It applies only if it is claimed on a return, and the purchase is notifiable, so a return is due even though nothing is payable. At S Ltd, none had been filed. Whichever way the freehold is held, a peppercorn extension carries no stamp duty. Where a new lease is granted in return for surrendering the old one between the same parties, neither the surrender nor the grant counts as consideration for the other, so only an actual cash premium is ever charged. A 999-year lease at a peppercorn, with no premium, is not even notifiable, so there is nothing to file. If the company holds as nominee, that is the end of it. The leaseholder is in substance extending their own lease, so there is no acquisition to tax. If the company owns the freehold in its own right, the peppercorn grant still carries no stamp duty, but it is not the end of the story, because value has moved out of the company to its shareholders for nothing. The catch: In the beneficial owner case, handing the shareholders a lease worth market value for a peppercorn is treated either as a distribution out of the company, taxable on them as income, or as a loan to them as participators, which brings its own charge on the company. Paying a proper premium would avoid that, but then the extension becomes notifiable and stamp duty is due on the premium. S Ltd did the right thing on the ground. It bought its freehold and extended its leases. What it was left with was tax and filing that nobody had costed. Particulars Where It Stands Capacity The company owns the freehold in its own right, because there was no declaration of trust. The arrangements all leaned towards it. The company received ground rents, etc. SDLT on the purchase Nil under section 74, but the return was never filed, so late filing penalties are running on a bill that was always zero. Corporation tax on the extensions A chargeable gain of £150,000, about £37,500 at the 25% rate, not brought into the company's return. Cash to pay it None in the company, so the leaseholders have to fund the bill. Ground rent income Taxed on the company, not the leaseholders, because the company is the owner. The leaseholders still got what they wanted. They also got a set of returns to put right, a bill to fund, and a company that will keep being taxed on income they may have assumed was theirs. Most of it was avoidable, and advice at the outset would have changed the picture. The corporation tax charge of about £37,500 followed from how the company acquired the freehold and the paperwork that recorded it. Had it been held on the right basis from the outset, the same purchase and the same lease extensions would have produced a very different result. Acquire on a Bare Trust - The company takes the title as nominee for the leaseholders, under a declaration of trust recording each one's share. Fund It As Their Own Money - Each contribution goes in as the leaseholder's own, backed by the trust deed, a participation agreement and the payment records. Grant the Extended Leases Straight After Completion – Do this while the freehold is still worth what was just paid for it. SDLT Remains Unchanged - The purchase still qualifies for section 74 relief, so the tax is nil, and a peppercorn extension carries none. The return still has to be filed. Corporation Tax - None, and the company can stay dormant. Holding only as nominee, the company has no income or gains of its own. The extensions are the leaseholders’ own transactions, so the £37,500 charge never arises. The ground rents belong to the leaseholders and are taxed on them, and the service charge sits on the statutory trust under section 42 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 , so neither is the company's money. A freehold company in this position is usually treated as dormant for corporation tax, filing dormant accounts at Companies House. Capital Gains is Minimal, If the Timing is Right - On each grant, the other leaseholders make a small disposal of their share of that flat's reversion. Done straight after completion, the reversion is worth barely more than it cost, so there is almost nothing to tax, and the small gains are usually covered by the annual exempt amount. Leaving the extensions for years, as S Ltd did, is what let the reversion grow into the gain that was taxed. If your company holds an enfranchised freehold, four questions decide where you stand: Capacity - Nominee under a declaration of trust, or owner in its own right? That alone decides who is taxed. Stamp Duty Land Tax - Was the SDLT1 filed and section 74 relief claimed, even though the tax was nil? Lease Extensions - Did granting them create a part disposal that nobody costed? Timing - Are you asking these questions before the deal, when they can still change the answer, or after? Buying your freehold together is worth doing. It is not tax-free, though. Whether the company holds the freehold for you or in its own name decides who pays, and that is settled at the start, in the paperwork, not on the day you extend. Get it right early, and the stamp duty is nil, the extensions are clean, and there is nothing to unwind. Get it late, and the same deal leaves an unfiled return and a corporation tax bill no one budgeted for. If your building is thinking about buying its freehold, take advice before you fund it, not after you have granted the leases. buying-freehold-and-collective-enfranchisement buying freehold and collective enfranchisement page Page




