Skip to main content
Snehaja Rajyalaxmi Thapa

Snehaja Rajyalaxmi Thapa

Snehaja is a legal professional with expertise in legal drafting, policy research, and corporate compliance, holding a BBM LLB degree and nearly a year of multidisciplinary experience. She is passionate about promoting legal awareness and delivering practical, informed solutions.

Published entries

SDLT residential classification based on a property's physical structure rather than occupancy readiness

7/30/2025

SDLT Defined by Physical Structure, Not Occupancy Readiness: Patel v HMRC

SDLT Defined by Physical Structure, Not Occupancy Readiness: Patel v HMRC SDLT Defined by Physical Structure, Not Occupancy Readiness: Patel v HMRC The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) recently delivered a significant ruling clarifying the distinction between "use" and "occupation" when determining residential property classification for [[stamp-duty-land-tax-sdlt|Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT)]] purposes. The case involved two partially constructed properties in London, where the construction had stalled. Due to planning restrictions that prohibited occupation until a separate, unrelated development was complete, the site was essentially a building site with scaffolding, exposed structures, and incomplete works. The appellant had attempted to acquire that other property to lift the restriction but was ultimately unsuccessful. Hence, although SDLT was initially paid on a residential basis, the appellant later pursued a refund through the overpayment relief route, contending that the property should be considered non-residential. HMRC refused this claim. The FTT, relying on a multi-factorial approach, focused on the objective nature of the chargeable interest acquired to assess the property's essential characteristics at completion date. Applying the reasoning provided in Mudan v HMRC [2024] UKUT 307 (TCC) , the FTT distinguished between "use" and "occupation," finding that these terms are not synonymous when determining whether a property is residential. Although the planning restriction imposed a prohibition on occupation pending completion of the other property, it did not affect the essential characteristics and nature of the building as a dwelling. Instead, it created a non-permanent restriction that could be satisfied upon completion of the linked development. These do not negate a building's fundamental suitability for use as a dwelling where they merely delay occupation rather than permanently preclude residential use. To summarise, the FTT's emphasis that temporary restrictions on occupation do not automatically disqualify a property from being classified as residential for SDLT purposes reinforces that such classification hinges on the property's objective physical characteristics, rather than buyer-specific barriers to occupation. This interpretation extends the use/occupation distinction established in Mudan beyond issues of repair, applying it also to planning-related restrictions. Full decision: Bemal Patel v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 373 (TC) . sdlt-defined-by-physical-structure-not-occupancy-readiness-patel-v-hmrc sdlt defined by physical structure not occupancy readiness patel v hmrc page Page

Lynch & Anor vs HMRC: SDLT mixed use claim denied

6/17/2025

Lynch & Anor vs HMRC: Interpreting Mixed Use Stamp Duty Land Tax Claims on Agricultural Land

Lynch & Anor vs HMRC: Interpreting Mixed Use Stamp Duty Land Tax Claims on Agricultural Land Lynch & Anor vs HMRC: Interpreting Mixed Use Stamp Duty Land Tax Claims on Agricultural Land Background Facts Legal Issue Appellant's and Respondent's Arguments Appellant's and Respondent's Arguments Holding Reasoning Reasoning Conclusion Understanding the specifications and implications of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT), especially the concept related to mixed-use properties, is essential when buying property in England. When a property has both residential and non-residential components, such property are considered as a mixed-use property and is assessed at non-residential SDLT rates, which are lower than residential SDLT rates, resulting in SDLT savings for the buyer. This case before the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) examines the distinction between residential "grounds" and commercially used land, specifically addressing whether agricultural grazing arrangements can establish mixed-use status for SDLT purposes. Mr. Martin and Mrs. Julia Lynch (the “Appellant”) purchased a property on 7 May 2021, The Property consisted of a large, five-bedroom house, a one-bedroom converted barn, a two-bedroom cottage, various domestic outbuildings and 22 acres of land (together the “Property”). The 22 acres of land included extensive formal gardens, a kitchen garden, and 18 acres of paddocks (“Grazing land”). The purchase price of the Property is £3,075,000, and Appellants paid SDLT of £258,750 on the basis that the Property was wholly residential and applied for Multiple Dwellings Relief (MDR) . At the time of purchase, the Property included grazing land that was being utilised by Mr. Watts (“a farmer”) for the purpose of grazing his beef cattle. No formal grazing agreement existed between the parties; instead, the arrangement operated under informal arrangement in the continuation of the operational practices that had been established under the previous ownership. On 5 May 2022, the Appellant filed a claim to HMRC for overpayment relief amount of £104,433. The application was submitted under the provisions of Schedule 10, Paragraph 34 of the Finance Act 2003, which grants taxpayers the statutory right to claim relief where SDLT has been overpaid on a property transaction. Following, HMRC issued a closure notice that reduced the Appellant's claim to nil, thereby denying the relief, which resulted in the Property being classified as residential. On 19 May 2023, the Appellant appealed to the FTT challenging HMRC's decision to deny the SDLT overpayment relief claim. Whether the 18 acres of grazing land formed part of the “grounds” of the dwelling under section 116(1)(b) of the Finance Act 2003, thus rendering the entire property residential for SDLT purposes or whether it had a sufficiently separate commercial function to make the property "mixed use."? The Appellants contended that the grazing arrangements were sufficiently commercial in nature to take the 18 acres outside the definition of "grounds" under Section 116 (1) (b) of the Finance Act 2003. They argued that The Grazing Land was, at the Effective Date of the transaction, being used by a third party for his own business use, namely, grazing cattle to fatten and sell them. The Grazing Land could not be seen from the house and did not form part of the “treasured view” which was a selling point of the Property as per its advertising brochure. The Grazing Land did not contribute to the security and privacy of the dwelling. On the contrary, the use of the land by a third party and the use of the footpaths by the public made it the least secure part of the Property. The Appellants did not need such a large piece of land and had no use for the Grazing Land. Indeed, they found it something of a liability when they had to maintain it themselves. The grazing arrangements were an intrusion on the Property. On the contrary, HMRC argued that the grazing arrangements were not genuinely commercial but rather constituted a mere informal understanding that suited both parties without creating a true commercial relationship. They emphasized that the rent was nominal in nature and that the arrangement was primarily beneficial to both parties for practical land management reasons rather than commercial profit. HMRC contended that the informal nature of the arrangements, the lack of any formal agreement at completion, and the Appellants' failure to receive any consideration during their ownership period demonstrated that this was not a commercial use sufficient to take the land outside the "grounds" definition. They argued that the land retained its character as grounds because the Appellants maintained full control and access rights, the farmer had no exclusive possession, and the arrangements could be terminated at will. HMRC further argued that the substantial size and rural character of the property meant that 18 acres was proportionate and appropriate for grounds of such a dwelling, and that the land continued to contribute to the overall residential setting and character of the property. The FTT dismissed the appeal, holding that the 18 acres of grazing land constituted "grounds" of the dwelling, making the entire Property wholly residential and confirming that the correct amount of SDLT was paid, hence no relief to be claimed. The FTT applied a multi-factorial test, which states that no one factor is determinative, and different factors may be given different weight. The FTT must carry out a balancing exercise, weighing up all the factors to come to a balanced judgement as to whether the land in question constitutes “grounds” of a dwelling established in the Hyman case, giving weight to the actual use of the land and whether it is separate from the dwelling. While the land was used by a third party for his commercial cattle business, several factors supported the "grounds" classification such as: the land was purchased in a single transaction with common ownership, was adjacent to the formal gardens, was of appropriate size for a substantial country property, and the farmer did not have exclusive possession. The FTT found that the grazing arrangements were informal and non-commercial from the Appellants' perspective, as they received no consideration and could terminate the arrangement at their will. Critically, the FTT determined that the grazing use did not prevent the land from functioning as an "appendage" to the dwelling and was not separate from the residential use of the main house. The Appellants retained full rights over the land and could use it whenever they wished. This case became a cautionary lesson for anyone buying rural properties with agricultural elements in it. This demonstrated that, in the world of tax law, intentions, traditional arrangements, and even agricultural use are insufficient to prevent agricultural land from being classified as "grounds" of a residential property for SDLT purposes. If you want a mixed-use SDLT treatment, you will have to have: Any form of formal written agreement between two parties such as Farming Business Tenancy, etc. Have exclusive commercial rights, Legal separation between residential and commercial elements and Documentation that would satisfy a tax tribunal. Lynch and Anor vs HMRC case: FTT rules grazing land as residential "grounds," rejecting SDLT mixed-use relief. Lynch and Anor vs HMRC lynch-and-anor-vs-hmrc-interpreting-mixed-use-stamp-duty-land-tax-claims-on-agricultural-land lynch and anor vs hmrc interpreting mixed use stamp duty land tax claims on agricultural land page Page