
10/9/2026
Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief
Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief Introduction A separate 2026 development: Key Takeaways What Has HMRC Actually Changed in CG65715? Why Does the Business Test Matter for Landlord Incorporation Relief? Where Did the 20-Hour Figure Come From in the First Place? What Prompted HMRC to Revisit the CG65715 Guidance? What Does the Updated Guidance Mean for Landlords Considering Incorporation? What Factors Will HMRC Look At Where the Landlord Works Fewer Than 20 Hours? Does the "Personally Undertaking" Issue Remain Unresolved? Worked Example of 20 Hour Incorporation Relief Rule Frequently Asked Questions Did HMRC’s 20 August update change section 162 itself? What if the landlord uses a managing agent for most of the day-to-day work? What other section 162 conditions need to be satisfied? Conclusion HMRC has updated its guidance on the 20-hour rule for incorporation relief, and the change matters to every landlord thinking about transferring a property portfolio to a company. On 20 August 2026, HMRC amended Capital Gains Manual CG65715 to confirm that a landlord spending fewer than 20 hours a week on property activities may still be carrying on a business. The published wording now expressly recognises what practitioners have long argued from case law: the hours worked are one factor in a wider inquiry, rather than a numerical threshold. This article explains what has changed, why it matters, and how landlords should approach the business test when considering incorporation. Following an amendment to section 162 by Finance Act 2026, Incorporation Relief no longer applies automatically. For transfers on or after 6 April 2026, the taxpayer must actively claim the relief on the self-assessment tax return for the year of transfer. The claim must be made by the first anniversary of the 31 January following that tax year. Fewer than 20 hours a week no longer disqualifies a landlord. HMRC's updated guidance confirms that activities below the 20-hour figure may still amount to a business. Twenty hours or more of personal activity of the kind described in the guidance remains HMRC's published acceptance benchmark for the business issue. For landlords below 20 hours a week, HMRC must now decide the case on the full picture of the activity. Contemporaneous records of what the landlord actually does are the key evidence. The underlying legal test has not changed. It remains the fact-based approach in Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 226 (TCC), which looks at the nature and overall degree of the landlord's activities. On 20 August 2026, HMRC amended the paragraph in CG65715 dealing with landlords below the 20-hour threshold. The current published wording reads: You should accept that incorporation relief will be available where an individual spends 20 hours or more a week personally undertaking the sort of activities that are indicative of a business. Other cases, where an individual spends fewer than 20 hours a week, should be considered carefully because the activities may still be considered a business for section 162 purposes. You should determine the facts then consider the factors set out above to decide whether the activities amount to a business. The previous wording stopped after telling officers that other cases should be "considered carefully". The revised guidance goes materially further. It now states expressly that activities below 20 hours may still constitute a business for section 162 purposes and instructs officers to establish the facts before applying the wider business factors. HMRC's own update record describes the amendment as a clarification of its approach where fewer than 20 hours a week are spent on the activities. To know more about incorporation relief and how it works, refer to our related article Section 162 Incorporation Relief . Incorporation relief under section 162 TCGA 1992 defers the capital gain arising when an individual transfers a business as a going concern to a company in exchange for shares. The threshold question, and the one the manual is concerned with, is whether the individual is transferring a business . For most trading incorporations this is uncontroversial. For property lettings it is often the central issue, because the activity has some of the features of an investment as well as some of the features of a business. Section 162 uses the word "business" rather than "trade", the word is not defined for the purposes of TCGA 1992, and whether a particular activity amounts to a business is therefore a question of fact to be decided by reference to the case law. HMRC's 20-hour benchmark has its origin in Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 226 (TCC), the Upper Tribunal decision now widely accepted as the leading authority on the meaning of business for section 162. Mrs Ramsay let a property that had been divided into ten flats. The First-tier Tribunal held that her activities were normal and incidental to the owning of an investment property and did not amount to a business. The Upper Tribunal disagreed. Judge Berner set out a series of factors drawn from the earlier case law, in particular the tests derived from Customs and Excise Commissioners v Lord Fisher [1981] STC 238. He asked whether the activity was a serious undertaking earnestly pursued, whether it had continuity and substance, whether it was conducted on sound business principles, and whether it was of a kind commonly undertaken with a view to profit. Crucially, Judge Berner also identified the extent of the activities as an important additional factor. He said it was "the degree of activity as a whole which is material to the question whether there is a business, and not the extent of that activity when compared to the number of properties or lettings." The evidence accepted by the Upper Tribunal was that Mrs Ramsay and her husband spent approximately 20 hours per week between them carrying out the relevant property activities. The Tribunal did not turn that factual finding into a statutory minimum-hours test. The clarification followed an open letter to HMRC published by Property118 in July 2026. The letter asked HMRC to address two aspects of the manual: The 20-hour figure. Property118 argued that some HMRC officers were applying the 20 hours as a numerical threshold, and that this was inconsistent with the reasoning in Ramsay v HMRC. "Personally undertaking". The letter also asked HMRC to clarify how activities carried out through managing agents, employees, contractors and professional advisers should be treated, given that HMRC's wording requires the individual to be personally undertaking the relevant activities. The August amendment addressed the first point. It did not resolve the second. There are three practical messages: First, fewer than 20 hours a week is no longer a reason on its own to conclude that no business exists. This is the substantive change. A landlord spending 10, 12 or 15 hours a week on genuinely business-like property activities is now expressly within scope. Officers are directed to look at the facts and apply the Ramsay v HMRC factors. Second, everything now turns on the wider factual picture. For landlords below the 20-hour benchmark, the case will be decided on the nature, continuity, scale and commercial character of the activity as a whole. Contemporaneous records of what the landlord actually does become the key evidence. Third, 20 hours has not disappeared. It remains HMRC's published acceptance point for landlords personally undertaking activities of the type described in the guidance. Landlords who can genuinely evidence 20 hours or more a week are still in a better published position on the business question. Where a landlord spends fewer than 20 hours a week on property activities, the factors relevant to determine if the activities constitute a business are: Is the activity a serious undertaking, rather than a passive holding of investments? Is it pursued with reasonable and recognisable continuity? Is there substance in the operation, for example in terms of turnover or scale? Are the activities conducted in a regular manner and on sound business principles? Are they of a kind commonly carried on by those seeking to profit from them?[ What is the overall degree and extent of the activities, viewed as a whole? The evidence that supports a positive answer includes tenancy management records, refurbishment and capital improvement project files, correspondence with tenants, contractors and agents, records of rent reviews and re-lettings, financing activity, compliance records for gas, electrical and fire safety, and records of acquisitions and disposals. Meetings, a diary of property work, and structured management accounts all help to show that the activity is regular and organised. Recording time actually spent is not a statutory requirement, but a well-kept time record materially strengthens the position by showing what is being done and how frequently. Yes. This is an important area of continuing uncertainty. HMRC's 20-hour acceptance wording continues to refer to an individual "personally undertaking" the relevant activities. Section 162 itself does not use that wording, so the phrase is HMRC manual language rather than statutory language. The August amendment clarifies what officers should do where an individual spends fewer than 20 hours on the relevant activities, but it does not expressly explain what weight should be given to activities undertaken through employees, managing agents, contractors or professional advisers. This distinction matters for landlords who retain strategic and supervisory responsibility for a portfolio while delegating routine management. Property118 specifically asked HMRC to clarify this point. The August amendment did not do so. Ramsay v HMRC does not resolve the issue either, because the factual finding in that case was that Mrs Ramsay and her husband themselves carried out the relevant activities. Where substantial functions are delegated, the extent to which those activities contribute to the section 162 business analysis therefore remains fact sensitive. The safer course, pending further HMRC clarification, is to keep evidence of the landlord's own decision-making, supervision and time spent on portfolio matters, alongside the records maintained by the agent. Mr Patel owns a portfolio of six residential properties in Greater London. He is considering incorporating the portfolio into a limited company and claiming incorporation relief. The transfer is planned for the tax year 2026/27. He estimates that he personally spends around 12 hours a week on the portfolio, made up as follows: Activity Hours per week Tenant communication, viewings and lettings work 3.0 Rent collection, arrears follow-up and bank reconciliation 1.5 Repair and maintenance instructions, contractor coordination 2.5 Refurbishment project management (one property in works) 3.0 Compliance work (gas, electrical, EPC, deposits) 1.0 Bookkeeping, accounts and tax records 1.0 Total 12.0 Under the previous version of the guidance, Mr Patel's position below 20 hours would have been unclear. Officers were told to consider such cases carefully , but the manual did not expressly state that they could still qualify. Under the current guidance, the officer is directed to determine the facts and apply in Ramsay v HMRC factors. Mr Patel's activities cover tenant management, contractor coordination, compliance and refurbishment. They are pursued continuously across the year and conducted on regular and recognised business principles. The refurbishment activity would be one relevant factor when considering the nature and extent of the activities as a whole. On the totality of the activities, there is a reasonable argument that Mr Patel is carrying on a business for section 162 purposes despite spending fewer than 20 hours a week. The result is not automatic. Contemporaneous evidence would materially strengthen Mr Patel's position, and he will still need to satisfy the other conditions in section 162, including transferring the business as a going concern with the whole of the assets other than cash, and receiving shares in exchange. Because the proposed transfer takes place after 5 April 2026, Mr Patel would also need to make a valid section 162 claim on his self-assessment return within the statutory time limit. On a transfer in the 2026-27 tax year, that claim is due by 31 January 2029. The 20-hour acceptance point: If the agent handles the bulk of the day-to-day work, Mr Patel's own hours fall away and HMRC's acceptance point becomes harder to meet. The wider business question: Losing the acceptance point does not mean no business exists. Many businesses operate through agents, and the activity carried on through an agent is still part of the business carried on by the owner. The case then has to be made on the Ramsay factors as a whole. These figures are illustrative. The correct tax treatment depends on the specific facts. No. The amendment to the manual changes HMRC’s published guidance on the meaning of “business”. It does not introduce a new statutory hours test or amend the business requirement in section 162. Section 162 was, however, separately amended by Finance Act 2026. For business transfers on or after 6 April 2026, Incorporation Relief must be claimed on the taxpayer’s self-assessment return, and the claim must be made by the first anniversary of the 31 January following the tax year of transfer. This is the area the August amendment did not resolve. HMRC’s 20-hour acceptance wording still refers to the individual “personally undertaking” the activities, and it has not clarified how delegated activity should be weighed in the wider factual assessment. The prudent course is to keep evidence of the landlord’s own decision-making, supervision and time spent on portfolio matters, alongside the agent’s records. The business must be transferred as a going concern, together with the whole of the assets of the business other than cash. The consideration must be wholly or partly in shares issued by the company. Where the consideration is only partly in shares, only the proportion attributable to shares is deferred; cash or director’s loan consideration reduces the amount rolled over. The amendment to the manual does not change the law on incorporation relief, but it does change the way HMRC applies it to landlords who work fewer than 20 hours a week on their properties. For years, the 20-hour figure has done more work in practice than the case law justified. The revised paragraph brings HMRC's published position closer to the fact-sensitive approach that Ramsay v HMRC always required. The complexity has not gone away. The business test remains one of the most contested aspects of the section 162 conditions, the treatment of delegated activity is still unresolved, and the separate Finance Act 2026 claim requirement now imposes an obligation on the taxpayer for transfers on or after 6 April 2026. Landlords considering incorporation should treat the updated 20-hour rule as a clarification to be relied on with evidence, not as an automatic pass. Careful fact gathering, contemporaneous records, and a proper section 162 review well before the transfer are the safest route to a defensible position. To find out how this applies to your portfolio, book your free 15-minute discovery call today! Contact Us Now hmrc-20-hours-rule-for-landlord-incorporation-relief hmrc 20 hours rule for landlord incorporation relief page Page







