Skip to main content
Yogyata Dangal

Yogyata Dangal

Yogyata Dangal is an ACCA finalist specialising in UK tax and regulatory compliance. Meticulous and detail-oriented, Yogyata takes a disciplined approach to her work, focusing on delivering clear and specific outcomes. By combining strong analytical abilities with clear communication, she helps clients understand their obligations while ensuring their tax affairs are handled with precision and care.

Published entries

HMRC clarifies the 20-hour rule for landlord incorporation relief

10/9/2026

Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief

Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief Can a Landlord Working Under 20 Hours a Week Still Claim Incorporation Relief Introduction A separate 2026 development: Key Takeaways What Has HMRC Actually Changed in CG65715? Why Does the Business Test Matter for Landlord Incorporation Relief? Where Did the 20-Hour Figure Come From in the First Place? What Prompted HMRC to Revisit the CG65715 Guidance? What Does the Updated Guidance Mean for Landlords Considering Incorporation? What Factors Will HMRC Look At Where the Landlord Works Fewer Than 20 Hours? Does the "Personally Undertaking" Issue Remain Unresolved? Worked Example of 20 Hour Incorporation Relief Rule Frequently Asked Questions Did HMRC’s 20 August update change section 162 itself? What if the landlord uses a managing agent for most of the day-to-day work? What other section 162 conditions need to be satisfied? Conclusion HMRC has updated its guidance on the 20-hour rule for incorporation relief, and the change matters to every landlord thinking about transferring a property portfolio to a company. On 20 August 2026, HMRC amended Capital Gains Manual CG65715 to confirm that a landlord spending fewer than 20 hours a week on property activities may still be carrying on a business. The published wording now expressly recognises what practitioners have long argued from case law: the hours worked are one factor in a wider inquiry, rather than a numerical threshold. This article explains what has changed, why it matters, and how landlords should approach the business test when considering incorporation. Following an amendment to section 162 by Finance Act 2026, Incorporation Relief no longer applies automatically. For transfers on or after 6 April 2026, the taxpayer must actively claim the relief on the self-assessment tax return for the year of transfer. The claim must be made by the first anniversary of the 31 January following that tax year. Fewer than 20 hours a week no longer disqualifies a landlord. HMRC's updated guidance confirms that activities below the 20-hour figure may still amount to a business. Twenty hours or more of personal activity of the kind described in the guidance remains HMRC's published acceptance benchmark for the business issue. For landlords below 20 hours a week, HMRC must now decide the case on the full picture of the activity. Contemporaneous records of what the landlord actually does are the key evidence. The underlying legal test has not changed. It remains the fact-based approach in Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 226 (TCC), which looks at the nature and overall degree of the landlord's activities. On 20 August 2026, HMRC amended the paragraph in CG65715 dealing with landlords below the 20-hour threshold. The current published wording reads: You should accept that incorporation relief will be available where an individual spends 20 hours or more a week personally undertaking the sort of activities that are indicative of a business. Other cases, where an individual spends fewer than 20 hours a week, should be considered carefully because the activities may still be considered a business for section 162 purposes. You should determine the facts then consider the factors set out above to decide whether the activities amount to a business. The previous wording stopped after telling officers that other cases should be "considered carefully". The revised guidance goes materially further. It now states expressly that activities below 20 hours may still constitute a business for section 162 purposes and instructs officers to establish the facts before applying the wider business factors. HMRC's own update record describes the amendment as a clarification of its approach where fewer than 20 hours a week are spent on the activities. To know more about incorporation relief and how it works, refer to our related article Section 162 Incorporation Relief . Incorporation relief under section 162 TCGA 1992 defers the capital gain arising when an individual transfers a business as a going concern to a company in exchange for shares. The threshold question, and the one the manual is concerned with, is whether the individual is transferring a business . For most trading incorporations this is uncontroversial. For property lettings it is often the central issue, because the activity has some of the features of an investment as well as some of the features of a business. Section 162 uses the word "business" rather than "trade", the word is not defined for the purposes of TCGA 1992, and whether a particular activity amounts to a business is therefore a question of fact to be decided by reference to the case law. HMRC's 20-hour benchmark has its origin in Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 226 (TCC), the Upper Tribunal decision now widely accepted as the leading authority on the meaning of business for section 162. Mrs Ramsay let a property that had been divided into ten flats. The First-tier Tribunal held that her activities were normal and incidental to the owning of an investment property and did not amount to a business. The Upper Tribunal disagreed. Judge Berner set out a series of factors drawn from the earlier case law, in particular the tests derived from Customs and Excise Commissioners v Lord Fisher [1981] STC 238. He asked whether the activity was a serious undertaking earnestly pursued, whether it had continuity and substance, whether it was conducted on sound business principles, and whether it was of a kind commonly undertaken with a view to profit. Crucially, Judge Berner also identified the extent of the activities as an important additional factor. He said it was "the degree of activity as a whole which is material to the question whether there is a business, and not the extent of that activity when compared to the number of properties or lettings." The evidence accepted by the Upper Tribunal was that Mrs Ramsay and her husband spent approximately 20 hours per week between them carrying out the relevant property activities. The Tribunal did not turn that factual finding into a statutory minimum-hours test. The clarification followed an open letter to HMRC published by Property118 in July 2026. The letter asked HMRC to address two aspects of the manual: The 20-hour figure. Property118 argued that some HMRC officers were applying the 20 hours as a numerical threshold, and that this was inconsistent with the reasoning in Ramsay v HMRC. "Personally undertaking". The letter also asked HMRC to clarify how activities carried out through managing agents, employees, contractors and professional advisers should be treated, given that HMRC's wording requires the individual to be personally undertaking the relevant activities. The August amendment addressed the first point. It did not resolve the second. There are three practical messages: First, fewer than 20 hours a week is no longer a reason on its own to conclude that no business exists. This is the substantive change. A landlord spending 10, 12 or 15 hours a week on genuinely business-like property activities is now expressly within scope. Officers are directed to look at the facts and apply the Ramsay v HMRC factors. Second, everything now turns on the wider factual picture. For landlords below the 20-hour benchmark, the case will be decided on the nature, continuity, scale and commercial character of the activity as a whole. Contemporaneous records of what the landlord actually does become the key evidence. Third, 20 hours has not disappeared. It remains HMRC's published acceptance point for landlords personally undertaking activities of the type described in the guidance. Landlords who can genuinely evidence 20 hours or more a week are still in a better published position on the business question. Where a landlord spends fewer than 20 hours a week on property activities, the factors relevant to determine if the activities constitute a business are: Is the activity a serious undertaking, rather than a passive holding of investments? Is it pursued with reasonable and recognisable continuity? Is there substance in the operation, for example in terms of turnover or scale? Are the activities conducted in a regular manner and on sound business principles? Are they of a kind commonly carried on by those seeking to profit from them?[ What is the overall degree and extent of the activities, viewed as a whole? The evidence that supports a positive answer includes tenancy management records, refurbishment and capital improvement project files, correspondence with tenants, contractors and agents, records of rent reviews and re-lettings, financing activity, compliance records for gas, electrical and fire safety, and records of acquisitions and disposals. Meetings, a diary of property work, and structured management accounts all help to show that the activity is regular and organised. Recording time actually spent is not a statutory requirement, but a well-kept time record materially strengthens the position by showing what is being done and how frequently. Yes. This is an important area of continuing uncertainty. HMRC's 20-hour acceptance wording continues to refer to an individual "personally undertaking" the relevant activities. Section 162 itself does not use that wording, so the phrase is HMRC manual language rather than statutory language. The August amendment clarifies what officers should do where an individual spends fewer than 20 hours on the relevant activities, but it does not expressly explain what weight should be given to activities undertaken through employees, managing agents, contractors or professional advisers. This distinction matters for landlords who retain strategic and supervisory responsibility for a portfolio while delegating routine management. Property118 specifically asked HMRC to clarify this point. The August amendment did not do so. Ramsay v HMRC does not resolve the issue either, because the factual finding in that case was that Mrs Ramsay and her husband themselves carried out the relevant activities. Where substantial functions are delegated, the extent to which those activities contribute to the section 162 business analysis therefore remains fact sensitive. The safer course, pending further HMRC clarification, is to keep evidence of the landlord's own decision-making, supervision and time spent on portfolio matters, alongside the records maintained by the agent. Mr Patel owns a portfolio of six residential properties in Greater London. He is considering incorporating the portfolio into a limited company and claiming incorporation relief. The transfer is planned for the tax year 2026/27. He estimates that he personally spends around 12 hours a week on the portfolio, made up as follows: Activity Hours per week Tenant communication, viewings and lettings work 3.0 Rent collection, arrears follow-up and bank reconciliation 1.5 Repair and maintenance instructions, contractor coordination 2.5 Refurbishment project management (one property in works) 3.0 Compliance work (gas, electrical, EPC, deposits) 1.0 Bookkeeping, accounts and tax records 1.0 Total 12.0 Under the previous version of the guidance, Mr Patel's position below 20 hours would have been unclear. Officers were told to consider such cases carefully , but the manual did not expressly state that they could still qualify. Under the current guidance, the officer is directed to determine the facts and apply in Ramsay v HMRC factors. Mr Patel's activities cover tenant management, contractor coordination, compliance and refurbishment. They are pursued continuously across the year and conducted on regular and recognised business principles. The refurbishment activity would be one relevant factor when considering the nature and extent of the activities as a whole. On the totality of the activities, there is a reasonable argument that Mr Patel is carrying on a business for section 162 purposes despite spending fewer than 20 hours a week. The result is not automatic. Contemporaneous evidence would materially strengthen Mr Patel's position, and he will still need to satisfy the other conditions in section 162, including transferring the business as a going concern with the whole of the assets other than cash, and receiving shares in exchange. Because the proposed transfer takes place after 5 April 2026, Mr Patel would also need to make a valid section 162 claim on his self-assessment return within the statutory time limit. On a transfer in the 2026-27 tax year, that claim is due by 31 January 2029. The 20-hour acceptance point: If the agent handles the bulk of the day-to-day work, Mr Patel's own hours fall away and HMRC's acceptance point becomes harder to meet. The wider business question: Losing the acceptance point does not mean no business exists. Many businesses operate through agents, and the activity carried on through an agent is still part of the business carried on by the owner. The case then has to be made on the Ramsay factors as a whole. These figures are illustrative. The correct tax treatment depends on the specific facts. No. The amendment to the manual changes HMRC’s published guidance on the meaning of “business”. It does not introduce a new statutory hours test or amend the business requirement in section 162. Section 162 was, however, separately amended by Finance Act 2026. For business transfers on or after 6 April 2026, Incorporation Relief must be claimed on the taxpayer’s self-assessment return, and the claim must be made by the first anniversary of the 31 January following the tax year of transfer. This is the area the August amendment did not resolve. HMRC’s 20-hour acceptance wording still refers to the individual “personally undertaking” the activities, and it has not clarified how delegated activity should be weighed in the wider factual assessment. The prudent course is to keep evidence of the landlord’s own decision-making, supervision and time spent on portfolio matters, alongside the agent’s records. The business must be transferred as a going concern, together with the whole of the assets of the business other than cash. The consideration must be wholly or partly in shares issued by the company. Where the consideration is only partly in shares, only the proportion attributable to shares is deferred; cash or director’s loan consideration reduces the amount rolled over. The amendment to the manual does not change the law on incorporation relief, but it does change the way HMRC applies it to landlords who work fewer than 20 hours a week on their properties. For years, the 20-hour figure has done more work in practice than the case law justified. The revised paragraph brings HMRC's published position closer to the fact-sensitive approach that Ramsay v HMRC always required. The complexity has not gone away. The business test remains one of the most contested aspects of the section 162 conditions, the treatment of delegated activity is still unresolved, and the separate Finance Act 2026 claim requirement now imposes an obligation on the taxpayer for transfers on or after 6 April 2026. Landlords considering incorporation should treat the updated 20-hour rule as a clarification to be relied on with evidence, not as an automatic pass. Careful fact gathering, contemporaneous records, and a proper section 162 review well before the transfer are the safest route to a defensible position. To find out how this applies to your portfolio, book your free 15-minute discovery call today! Contact Us Now hmrc-20-hours-rule-for-landlord-incorporation-relief hmrc 20 hours rule for landlord incorporation relief page Page

Gifting a property while continuing to live in it and the Pre-Owned Asset Tax risk

8/22/2026

Pre-Owned Asset Tax (POAT): How to Prevent the Charge on a Gifted Property

Pre-Owned Asset Tax (POAT): How to Prevent the Charge on a Gifted Property Pre-Owned Asset Tax (POAT): How to Prevent the Charge on a Gifted Property Introduction Key Takeaways How the Gift with Reservation Rules Work How Pre-Owned Asset Tax Works “But I Gave Away Cash, Not the Property” – The POAT Trap That Catches Landlords The seven-year exclusion Example The Lady Ingram Case: How the Anti-Avoidance Rules Developed GWR and POAT: How They Interact, and Why Only One Normally Applies The Safe Harbour: Section 102B(4) and How to Avoid Both GWR and POAT Worked Example: How a Property Share Gift Can Be Safe From Both GWR and POAT The facts: Why this works Documentation recommended to defend this position: Paying Full Market Rent on a Gifted Property Paying Full Market Rent on a Gifted Property Electing Into the Inheritance Tax Rules Instead of Pre-Owned Asset Tax Other Tax Risks of Gifting Property and How to Mitigate Them Conclusion Frequently Asked Questions Can POAT apply even if the property was bought with cash I gave away years ago? Can I elect out of POAT once it is running? Do I need to tell HMRC about the gift? Thinking of gifting your home, or a share of it, to your children while carrying on living there yourself? At first glance, it may look like the perfect plan. You take value out of your estate, you stay in the house you have always lived in, and the next generation inherits sooner rather than later. So where is the catch? The catch is that HMRC has seen this arrangement many times over, and it has built more than one set of rules to deal with it. Gifting property that you continue to live in or use can trigger several tax risks. The two principal anti-avoidance regimes are the gift with reservation of benefit rules (GWR), which can pull the property straight back into your estate so that the inheritance tax position is left unchanged, and the Pre-Owned Asset Tax (POAT), an annual income tax charge that can apply where you have given away property, cash or other value but continue occupying or enjoying property connected with that gift. Capital gains tax, stamp duty land tax, and residence nil-rate band issues can also arise. This article focuses on POAT and explains the main routes by which both GWR and POAT may be avoided, provided the relevant conditions continue to be met. Note For a fuller explanation of the GWR rules, read our companion article: All You Need to Know About Gift with Reservation of Benefit . Gifting property that you continue to live in can trigger two separate tax regimes: the gift with reservation of benefit rules (GWR), an inheritance tax charge under section 102 of the Finance Act 1986, and the Pre-Owned Asset Tax (POAT), an annual income tax charge under Schedule 15 to the Finance Act 2004. Only one of the two can apply to the same benefit from the same asset at the same time. Pre-Owned Asset Tax is an annual income tax charge that can apply where you have given away property or cash and then continue to occupy or benefit from property connected with those assets. It is calculated by reference to the open-market rental value attributable to the relevant disposal or contribution and is taxed at your marginal income tax rate. Where you gift a share of an existing property, and both you and the recipient genuinely occupy it with fair cost-sharing, section 102B(4) of the Finance Act 1986 can prevent both the GWR charge and the POAT charge. If you gift cash and the recipient uses it to buy a property that you later occupy, POAT may apply for each year of occupation. A limited exclusion may apply where the cash was given outright at least seven years before you first occupied the property. Paying a genuine full open-market rent may also prevent a GWR and eliminate the POAT charge, but the arrangement must remain commercial, and the rent must be reviewed regularly. The gift with reservation rules apply where an individual gives away property but continues to enjoy a benefit from it. In that situation, the property may still be treated as part of the donor’s estate for inheritance tax purposes, even though legal ownership has passed to someone else. If the donor continues to benefit from the property until death, the property is included in their estate at its value at that time. Taper relief does not apply because the property is treated as part of the death estate rather than as a lifetime transfer. If the donor stops benefiting from the property during their lifetime, the seven-year period starts from the date the benefit ends, rather than from the date of the original gift. If the donor dies more than three years but less than seven years after that date, taper relief may reduce any inheritance tax payable. POAT applies where you occupy a property, and either the disposal condition or the contribution condition is met, provided the relevant transaction occurred after 17 March 1986 and was not an excluded transaction. The two conditions are outlined below: The disposal condition applies where you previously owned the property and disposed of all or part of your interest in it. It can also apply where you owned another asset, disposed of that asset, and another person used the proceeds to acquire the property. The contribution condition applies where you directly or indirectly provided some or all of the money or other consideration used by another person to acquire the property. It can also apply where your contribution was used to acquire another asset which was later sold, with the proceeds used to acquire the property. Note POAT does not apply where the relevant disposal or contribution is an excluded transaction. Examples include a genuine sale of the whole interest at full market value on arm’s-length terms, certain transfers between spouses or civil partners, dispositions for family maintenance, some gifts covered by the annual exemption or small gifts exemption, and certain outright gifts of money (explored in detail later in this article). The charge is calculated by reference to the open-market rental value of the property, adjusted to reflect the proportion attributable to the interest disposed of or the contribution previously made by the occupier, where relevant. That amount is added to your taxable income and taxed at your marginal rate. So, if the relevant annual rental value is £20,000 and you are a higher rate taxpayer, the annual income tax charge would be £8,000 at a 40% rate. If you are an additional rate taxpayer, the charge would be £9,000 at a 45% rate. Different rates may apply to Scottish taxpayers. There is a de minimis exemption where the aggregate relevant POAT benefit for the year does not exceed £5,000. The test is based on the appropriate rental value of the property, before deducting rental payments (if any). If the relevant amount exceeds £5,000, the exemption is lost altogether. Crucially, even if you eventually move out, the charge runs for every year you were in occupation. There is no retrospective exemption once POAT has applied. You cannot simply decide to move out and escape the charge for the years you were there. The charge accrues as you go, and you are responsible for declaring it on your tax return for each year of occupation. If you gift cash rather than the property itself, the GWR provisions do not normally apply to the property that the recipient buys with that cash. You never owned the property, so how can you have reserved a benefit in it? This argument may appear plausible, and arrangements structured in this way can fall outside the GWR rules. However, POAT can apply even if you never owned the property yourself. For POAT purposes, what matters is that the cash or other value came from you, the recipient used it towards acquiring the property, and you later occupied that property. For example, you may give cash to your child, your child uses that money to buy a property, and you later move into it. POAT may apply because your gift helped fund the purchase of the property you now occupy. The same principle can apply where the connection is indirect. For example, your child may use your cash gift to buy another asset, later sell that asset, and use the proceeds to buy the property you occupy. A limited exclusion may apply where the contribution was an outright gift of money made at least seven years before you first occupied the property. Money, for these purposes, means cash. So, the exclusion does not apply where you gave another asset that was later sold, or where you made a loan that was subsequently written off. Note This is a narrow statutory exclusion and should not be treated as a general tax-planning strategy. A parent gives a child £300,000, which the child uses to buy a property. If the parent moves into the property three years later, POAT may apply for each year of occupation. If the contribution was an outright cash gift made at least seven years before the parent first occupied the property, the gift may fall within the seven-year exclusion, and POAT may not apply. To understand how the rules developed, consider the Lady Ingram case. In 1987, when she was aged 72, Lady Ingram owned a country house in Berkshire where she had lived for more than 40 years. She wanted to give the property to her children and grandchildren to reduce the inheritance tax on her estate, but she had no intention of leaving the house. Her advisers devised an ingenious solution. Lady Ingram conveyed the property to her solicitor, who granted her a 20-year lease. The solicitor then transferred the freehold reversion, being the ownership that would revert when the lease ended, to the family trustees. In this way, Lady Ingram kept the lease, which gave her the right to occupy the house, and gave away only the freehold reversion. The argument was elegant: what she gave away was the freehold subject to the lease. What she retained was the lease itself. Because she never gave away the lease, she could not have reserved a benefit in something she gave away. She had divided the cake before sharing it. The House of Lords agreed with her on 10 December 1998 in Ingram v IRC [1998] UKHL 47, [1999] STC 37 and [2000] 1 AC 293. No reservation of benefit had arisen. For a brief moment, the Ingram scheme looked like a legitimate route to giving away property while staying in it. Parliament responded quickly. Legislation applying to arrangements made on or after 9 March 1999 introduced section 102A of the Finance Act 1986 to catch arrangements of this type. Ingram-style schemes entered into on or after that date can therefore be treated as gifts with reservation. Older arrangements may instead fall within POAT, depending on the facts. The GWR rules come first and operate for inheritance tax purposes. POAT is the later-introduced income tax alternative that Parliament created because certain arrangements fell outside GWR. The two charges do not normally apply to the same benefit from the same asset at the same time. The POAT legislation contains exemptions intended to prevent an overlapping charge where the relevant property is already subject to the GWR rules. It also recognises certain statutory GWR exceptions, including the shared-occupation exception in section 102B(4). Understanding which regime applies is essential because the outcomes can be materially different. Under GWR, the property may remain within the donor’s estate for inheritance tax purposes. Under POAT, the donor may instead face an annual income tax charge for each year of occupation. Not all gifts of property trigger GWR or POAT. There is a powerful statutory safe harbour under section 102B(4) of the Finance Act 1986, designed for cases where you give away a share of a property but both you and the recipient genuinely continue to live there. Section 102B(4) disapplies the GWR charge where two conditions are met: (a) the donor and the donee occupy the land; and (b) the donor does not receive any benefit, other than a negligible one, which is provided by or at the expense of the donee for some reason connected with the gift. In simpler terms: both parties genuinely live in the property, and the donor is not being subsidised by the donee as a result of the gift. Where these conditions are satisfied, the gift of the share is not treated as a gift with reservation. Because POAT does not apply where property would be caught by GWR but for this express exception, Schedule 15 paragraph 11(5)(c) of the Finance Act 2004 also brings the property within the POAT exemption. Neither GWR nor POAT arises. The critical point is that the cohabitation requirement is not a one-off test passed on completion day. Section 102B(4) is a continuing condition. The relief holds only for as long as both donor and donee continue to occupy the property and the no-benefit condition is satisfied. If the donee ceases to occupy the property as their home, or if cost-sharing shifts so that one party subsidises the other, the protection may fall away from that point. A brief or temporary physical absence will not necessarily be decisive, but any material change in occupation should be reviewed. David and Sarah own their home in equal shares, and the property is valued at £2.1 million. Their adult son James has always lived with them. David and Sarah decide to gift a 50 per cent beneficial interest in the property to James. David and Sarah gift a 50 per cent undivided share to James. David and Sarah retain 50 per cent. All three continue occupying the property as their home. The three parties share the property costs in accordance with their respective interests: David and Sarah together pay 50 per cent of the agreed outgoings and James pays 50 per cent. The gift is unconditional and absolute. James genuinely enjoys his share and makes his own decisions about the property. James does not subsidise David and Sarah; the cost-sharing is fair. Each parent’s gift of their share of the interest to James will be a potentially exempt transfer. If they survive seven years and no reservation arises, the gifts will generally fall outside their estates. GWR does not apply because all parties continue to occupy the property and no collateral benefit flows from James to David and Sarah by reason of the gift. Section 102B(4) of the Finance Act 1986 is satisfied. David and Sarah’s continued occupation of their retained interest is not at James’s expense and does not detract from his enjoyment of his share. POAT does not apply because section 102B(4) is satisfied, which means Schedule 15 paragraph 11(5)(c) of the Finance Act 2004 brings the property within the POAT exemption. At the date of the gift: the transfer deed, Land Registry documentation showing the ownership split, a professional valuation of the interest transferred, mortgage lender consent where applicable, and evidence that James occupied the property. Annually thereafter : a written confirmation of continued occupation and cost-sharing, bank statement evidence of the payment of outgoings, and a file note confirming why section 102B(4) continues to apply. On David and Sarah’s deaths, HMRC may review the gift as part of the inheritance tax reporting. With a complete evidence file in place, the position should be easier to defend. Note The important caveat is that this protection is conditional on the facts continuing. If James ceases to occupy the property as his home, or if David and Sarah start paying less than their fair share so that James subsidises them, the protection may fall away from that point, and GWR may then apply, or where GWR does not apply, POAT may begin to run. The family must understand from the outset that the relief continues only while the qualifying occupation and no-benefit conditions are met. Where you pay full open-market rent, GWR and POAT may both be avoided. But the rent must be a genuine market rent, reviewed regularly and evidenced by formal occupation and payment records. HMRC may challenge nominal or below-market arrangements. For GWR purposes, Schedule 20 paragraph 6(1)(a) of the Finance Act 1986 provides that occupation for full consideration in money or money’s worth is disregarded when determining whether there is a reservation. The parties should obtain an independent rental valuation and enter into a tenancy agreement, licence or other occupation agreement appropriate to the circumstances. The rent should be paid regularly and reviewed at suitable intervals against current comparable rents. If the rent is not reviewed and later falls below the full market rate, a GWR may arise from that point. For POAT, payments that you are legally required to make to the owner for occupying the property reduce the chargeable amount. If those qualifying payments equal or exceed the appropriate rental value, the POAT chargeable amount will normally be nil. Where the full-consideration exception to GWR applies to the gift itself, Schedule 15 paragraph 11(5)(d) of the Finance Act 2004 may also provide a specific POAT exemption. The rent received will ordinarily be taxable property income of the recipient and must be reported to HMRC where required. This income tax cost should be taken into account when assessing whether the arrangement is suitable. A person who first becomes liable to POAT may be able to elect for the relevant property to be treated under the inheritance tax GWR rules instead. For land, the election must normally be made by 31 January following the first tax year in which the person is chargeable to POAT. It cannot be made if the person was already chargeable in an earlier year in relation to the same property or substituted property. The election takes effect for inheritance tax purposes from the date on which the POAT charge would first have arisen, but not earlier than 6 April 2005. From that date, the relevant chargeable portion of the property is treated as property subject to a reservation, and the corresponding POAT income tax charge does not apply. The election may be withdrawn or amended before the relevant filing date. As the election is made individually, each spouse or civil partner must decide if they each wish to avoid the POA charge. Planning point Before making the election, the likely future POAT cost should be compared with the potential inheritance tax exposure, taking account of the donor’s wider estate, available exemptions, expected property values and personal circumstances. Beyond GWR and POAT, gifting property creates other tax and legal risks that must be reviewed. Capital Gains Tax: A gift is a disposal for capital gains tax purposes. Where the gift is made between connected parties other than on an arm’s-length basis, it is treated as taking place at market value. If the property has increased in value since purchase, a capital gains tax liability may arise on the gift. Private residence relief may cover some or all of the gain, but this depends on the property’s occupation and letting history. If the property later remains in the donor’s estate under the GWR rules, that inheritance tax treatment does not generally give the recipient a fresh capital gains tax market-value base cost on the donor’s death. Stamp Duty Land Tax: A genuine gift of property in England or Northern Ireland will not normally give rise to SDLT if the recipient gives no chargeable consideration. If the recipient assumes responsibility for some or all of an existing mortgage or other secured debt, that debt may constitute chargeable consideration, and SDLT may then be payable. Separate land transaction taxes apply in Scotland and Wales. Residence Nil-Rate Band: Gifting a share of the property during lifetime may affect the residence nil-rate band position on death. The downsizing provisions may preserve some relief in appropriate cases. The wider inheritance tax position should be reviewed before proceeding. Mortgage Consent: A transfer of a mortgaged property will normally require the lender’s prior consent and may require the mortgage to be discharged or refinanced. The lender’s requirements should be confirmed before any legal or tax steps are taken. Pre-Owned Asset Tax is one of the most misunderstood tax charges affecting property owners. The temptation to gift cash rather than the property itself, or to gift a share of the home while staying in it, feels commercially sensible and is often well-intentioned. But without the right structure, documentation and ongoing compliance, the arrangement can expose you to a hidden annual income tax charge, running for every year you occupy the property and taxed at your marginal rate. Getting the structure right is essential. If you have already made an arrangement of this kind, establishing quickly whether GWR or POAT applies is important. If you are considering a property gift, taking proper advice before you act can make a significant difference to the outcome. Yes, POAT can apply if you gave away cash towards the acquisition of the property and then occupy it. The gift of cash can have been made many years before you occupy the property. A limited exclusion may apply where the contribution was an outright gift of money made at least seven years before the first relevant occupation. An election may be available for the first year in which you are chargeable to POAT, and it must normally be made by 31 January following that tax year. The relevant portion of the property is then treated under the GWR rules instead. The reporting position depends on the nature and value of the gift and the donor’s circumstances. POAT, if it applies, must be declared through Self Assessment for each relevant year of occupation. The recipient must also report any taxable rental where full market rent is paid. Paying full market rent on a gifted home to avoid gift with reservation and Pre-Owned Asset Tax charges poat-pre-owned-asset-tax poat pre owned asset tax page Page

Tax implications of transferring a business or rental property out of a limited company to its shareholders

5/5/2026

What Are the Tax Implications of Transferring a Business Out of a Company?

What Are the Tax Implications of Transferring a Business Out of a Company? What Are the Tax Implications of Transferring a Business Out of a Company? What Does Transferring a Business Out of a Company Actually Mean? Why Disincorporation is Rarely Tax Neutral When Might Disincorporation Arise? Corporation Tax on the Transfer of Assets Corporation Tax on the Transfer of Assets What happens to the company’s losses? How Transferring Property Out of a Company Affects Shareholders: Income Tax or Capital Gains Tax If the company is not closed If the company is closed through a Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL) If the company is struck off Does Disincorporation Trigger Stamp Duty Land Tax? Portfolios of six or more dwellings Stamp Duty or Stamp Duty Reserve Tax on shares What Happens to VAT, PAYE and Administration When You Disincorporate Your Business? Worked Example for Transferring Property Out of a Company Key Risks and Practical Considerations Conclusion Need advice on transferring a business out of a company? There are a number of reasons why a business owner might decide to move a business out of a company and into personal ownership. Perhaps the company structure has become more of a burden than a benefit, or the original reasons for incorporating no longer apply. In the property sector, disincorporation planning is a conversation we have regularly with clients who hold rental portfolios through a limited company and are now considering whether direct ownership would be simpler or more cost-effective. Transferring a business out of a company is rarely tax neutral. The company may pay corporation tax as if it had sold its assets at market value. The shareholders may then face income tax or capital gains tax when they receive those assets. If property is involved, stamp duty land tax may also arise. For property investment companies, the cost can be particularly high because many reliefs available to trading businesses will not apply. Note HMRC published guidance on this topic in December 2025, setting out the key considerations for companies and their shareholders. This article draws on that guidance and explains the practical implications, with a particular focus on property owners. In simple terms, it means moving the business and its assets from the company to the individuals who own it. The shareholders then continue running the business directly, either as sole traders or through a [[partnership-partnership-agreement-roles-types-benefits|partnership]]. HMRC refers to this process as disincorporation. Once the business has been transferred, the company itself is either closed down (through striking off or a members’ voluntary liquidation) or kept in existence, for example, as a dormant entity or for another purpose. Either way, the company and its owners are treated as separate legal persons, and the transfer of assets between them has tax consequences on both sides. When a business is moved out of a company, there are typically four main areas where tax can arise: Corporation tax The company is treated as having sold its assets at market value, even if nothing is actually paid. If the assets have gone up in value, a chargeable gain arises, and corporation tax is due. Income tax or capital gains tax for the shareholders When shareholders receive assets or cash from the company, they may be taxed on what they receive. The rate and type of tax depend on how the company is closed. Stamp duty land tax Where property is transferred, SDLT may be payable by the shareholders depending on the consideration they give. VAT, PAYE, and administration If the company is VAT-registered or has employees, there are registration and payroll matters to address. The company will also need to file final accounts and tax returns. Each of these is discussed in more detail below. The key point for now is that the tax cost can arise at several levels simultaneously, and the total can be substantial. We see disincorporation most commonly in the following situations: A property investor who incorporated several years ago but now finds the company structure restrictive, particularly around mortgage finance or profit extraction. A business owner approaching retirement who wants to simplify their affairs before winding down. A family restructuring where direct personal ownership of assets would be more practical or flexible. Cases where the tax position has shifted since incorporation, and the company wrapper is no longer delivering a net benefit. For property clients in particular, the decision often comes down to comparing the ongoing tax cost within the company (corporation tax plus extraction charges) against the cost of unwinding the structure. That comparison needs to account for all of the tax heads discussed below. When a company transfers its assets to shareholders , it is treated as having disposed of those assets at market value (the amount the company would get if it sold the asset to an unconnected person on the open market). The rule applies regardless of whether any money actually changes hands. If the market value on the date of transfer exceeds the original cost of the asset, a chargeable gain arises within the company. Corporation tax is charged on that gain at the main rate of 25% where profits are above £250,000, or at the small profits rate of 19% where profits do not exceed £50,000. [[corporation-tax-marginal-relief-uk-guide|Marginal relief]] applies where profits fall between these limits. The thresholds are reduced where the company has associated companies or where the accounting period is shorter than 12 months. For property companies, this is often a significant charge. Investment property held for several years is likely to have increased substantially in value. Although companies can still benefit from indexation allowance, it is calculated only up to December 2017, regardless of when the asset is later disposed of. For example, if a company bought a property in 2010 and transferred it to a shareholder in 2026, indexation can only cover the period from acquisition to December 2017. Any increase in value after that date is brought into charge without an inflation adjustment. Corporation tax losses do not pass through to shareholders. If the individuals continue to run the business personally, they cannot claim the company’s corporation tax losses. A trading company may be able to claim terminal loss relief, which allows trading losses from the final 12 months to be carried back against profits of the previous three years. However, this relief is only available in respect of trading losses. It does not apply to UK property business losses, which are subject to separate rules. Property income losses can generally only be set against profits of the same property business in the same period or carried forward while the property business continues. For most landlord companies, terminal loss relief will therefore not be available. The tax treatment for the individuals receiving the assets depends on how the company is dealt with after the transfer. This is a critical planning point and one that is often misunderstood. Whether the shareholder pays income tax or [[capital-gain-tax-guide|capital gains tax]] on the value extracted depends on if and how the company is closed. If the company continues to exist, for example, because it is made dormant or used for another purpose, assets transferred to shareholders will normally be treated as an income distribution. In practice, this means the shareholder is taxed in a similar way to receiving a dividend. For 2026/27, dividend tax rates are 10.75% for basic rate taxpayers, 35.75% for higher rate taxpayers, and 39.35% for additional rate taxpayers, after the £500 dividend allowance. The company must also have sufficient distributable reserves to make a lawful distribution, particularly where assets are transferred in specie rather than in cash. If the reserves are insufficient, the transfer may not constitute a valid distribution under company law, which can create further complications. Distributions made during a formal MVL are generally treated as capital rather than income. This means the shareholders pay capital gains tax on the difference between the value of the assets received and the base cost of their shares. The annual exempt amount (currently £3,000 for individuals) and any available reliefs can reduce the charge. Important point for property investment companies Business Asset Disposal Relief is aimed at trading businesses. From 6 April 2026, the BADR rate is 18% on qualifying gains up to the £1 million lifetime limit. This still represents a saving compared to the main higher rate of CGT at 24%, but it is significantly less generous than the 10% rate that applied before April 2025. A company that mainly holds buy to let or investment property will usually not qualify because its main activity is investment rather than trading. The position should still be checked where the company carries out property development, provides substantial services, or has mixed trading and investment activities. For most residential landlord companies, however, BADR will not be available. If the company is closed by voluntary striking off from the Companies Register, capital treatment is only available in limited cases. The total amount distributed before the company is dissolved must not exceed £25,000. The company must also have secured, or intend to secure, payment of debts due to it, and similarly have settled, or intend to settle, its debts and liabilities at the time of distribution. If the company has not been dissolved after two years have passed from a distribution, or the debts condition has not been satisfied by that time, the distributions are normally taxed as income rather than capital. The £25,000 limit applies to the company as a whole, not separately to each shareholder. This is a cliff-edge rule, so exceeding the limit can bring the whole distribution within [[income-tax-guide|income tax]] treatment. For companies with assets above this level, a formal MVL will usually produce a better tax outcome than a striking off. Anti-Avoidance Rules Anti-avoidance rules can apply where the arrangements are designed to turn what would otherwise be taxed as income into capital. This matters because capital gains tax can be lower than dividend income tax, especially where reliefs are available. For a winding up, the company winding-up TAAR (Targeted Anti-Avoidance Rule) can treat a capital distribution as income if all four conditions are met: the shareholder had at least a 5% interest in the company immediately before winding up the company was a close company at any point in the two years ending with the start of the winding up the shareholder continues the same or a similar trade or activity within two years from the date of the distribution one of the main purposes of the winding up is to avoid or reduce an income tax charge The Transactions in Securities rules may also need to be considered when arrangements involving shares or company distributions result in an income tax advantage. These rules are broader than the winding-up TAAR and may be relevant where the structure is designed to extract value in a more favourable tax form. HMRC statutory clearance is available for the Transactions in Securities rules, but not for the winding-up TAAR. Where the TAAR is a concern, the commercial reasons for the winding up should be clearly documented. Where the wider Transactions in Securities rules may apply, statutory clearance should be considered before the transaction proceeds. For property clients, [[stamp-duty-land-tax-sdlt|SDLT]] is often the most significant and sometimes the most overlooked cost in the entire exercise. When a company transfers land or property to its shareholders, SDLT is charged on the chargeable consideration given by the shareholders. In practice, this often means the amount the shareholder pays the company, or the amount of any mortgage debt assumed or refinanced by the shareholder on the transfer. If the property is transferred free of debt and no other consideration is given, there may be little or no SDLT charge. It is essential to note that in many real-world cases involving leveraged property, the debt assumption alone can produce a substantial SDLT bill. Where six or more dwellings are transferred in a single transaction, the transaction may be treated as non-residential for SDLT purposes. This can materially reduce the SDLT cost compared with applying residential rates and the higher rates surcharge. Care is needed where properties are transferred in stages or as part of a wider arrangement. If the transfers are linked, they may be treated as one transaction for SDLT purposes, which can affect the rates, thresholds and availability of six-dwelling treatment. If the company transfers shares it holds in other companies to its shareholders, Stamp Duty or Stamp Duty Reserve Tax may also need to be considered. Where the shares are transferred for consideration, Stamp Duty or SDRT is usually charged at 0.5% of the consideration given. If the shares are transferred for no consideration, Stamp Duty or SDRT will not usually be payable. However, special market value rules can apply in some connected company cases, particularly for listed shares. In those cases, the charge can be based on market value even where little or no consideration is paid. Alongside the tax charges, there are several practical compliance matters to deal with: VAT If the company is VAT registered, the transfer should be reviewed to confirm whether it qualifies as a transfer of a going concern (TOGC). Where the TOGC conditions are met, the transfer is outside the scope of VAT. VAT registration When a business moves from a limited company to a sole trader or partnership, its VAT registration may need to be transferred due to the change in legal status of the business. Alternatively, the company’s VAT registration may be cancelled, and the new business may be registered separately. PAYE If the company has employees or operates PAYE, payroll records, employee records, and final PAYE submissions should be dealt with before the transfer. Final filings Before the company is closed, all outstanding corporation tax returns, accounts, VAT returns, and Companies House filings should be brought up to date. The following example illustrates the cumulative tax cost of transferring a single rental property out of a company. The figures are simplified for illustration, and the assumptions are set out below. Assumptions The company purchased a buy-to-let property for £200,000 in 2015. Current market value is £500,000. Outstanding mortgage of £200,000 is assumed by the shareholder on transfer. The company is wound up through an MVL. The shareholder is a higher-rate taxpayer and already owns another residential property. BADR is not available (investment company). The shareholder’s base cost in the shares is assumed to be £200,000 for the purpose of this example. Item Amount Market value of property at transfer £500,000 Original cost to the company £200,000 Chargeable gain in the company £300,000 Corporation tax at 25% £75,000 Capital distribution to shareholders (MVL) £500,000 Less: base cost of shares (assumed) (£200,000) Gain for CGT purposes £300,000 CGT at 24% (higher rate, BADR unavailable) £72,000 SDLT on £200,000 debt assumed, applying higher rates for additional dwellings First £125,000 at 5% £6,250 Remaining £75,000 at 7% £5,250 Total SDLT £11,500 Total estimated tax cost £158,500 In this example, the total tax cost of extracting a property worth £500,000 is approximately £158,500, which represents around 32% of the property’s value. If the property were transferred without any mortgage debt being assumed, the SDLT charge could be significantly lower. Conversely, if the shareholder refinanced the property at a higher level, the SDLT cost would increase. For comparison, if the same property were purchased by the shareholder at full market value with a new £500,000 mortgage, the total SDLT would be £40,000, assuming the higher rates for additional dwellings apply. This shows how the structure of the transaction directly affects the overall tax cost. Double taxation is a real concern. The same economic gain can be taxed first within the company and again in the hands of the shareholder. There is no general relief to prevent this overlap. Valuations must be supportable. HMRC can challenge the market value adopted for the transfer, and an unsupported valuation creates risk on both the corporation tax and SDLT calculations. An independent valuation should be obtained for any material property transfer. There is no equivalent of [[section-162-incorporation-relief-landlords|incorporation relief]] in reverse. When a business is transferred into a company, the gain can be deferred. There is no corresponding provision for transferring a business out of a company. This asymmetry is one of the main reasons disincorporation is often tax inefficient. The commercial rationale matters. Where the transaction is primarily tax-motivated rather than commercially driven, the anti-avoidance provisions are more likely to be in point. For investment companies, the absence of BADR means the CGT charge at 24% can be substantial. This needs to be modelled at the outset. Lender consent and refinancing terms may be commercially decisive. For property clients, the mortgage position should be reviewed early in the process, because the ability to transfer or refinance the debt will often determine whether the transaction is feasible. The company must have sufficient distributable reserves to make any distribution, including transfers of assets in specie. If the reserves are unavailable, the transfer may not be lawful under company law. Transferring a business out of a company can be expensive and should not be treated as a simple administrative step. The company may be taxed on a market value disposal, the shareholders may be taxed on the value they receive, and property transfers can also trigger SDLT. Before proceeding, the shareholders should model the full tax cost, check the commercial position with lenders, obtain supportable valuations, and decide whether the company should be retained, struck off or placed into an MVL. Each case depends on its own facts, and early advice is essential. Our team at UK Property Accountants specialises in advising property investors and business owners on complex restructuring decisions. Contact us for a consultation to understand the full tax implications before making any changes to your company structure. Contact Us Company charged corporation tax on a market value disposal when it transfers property to its shareholders transferring-a-business-out-of-a-company transferring a business out of a company page Page

LLP and Taxation: 5 Tax Benefits Every Partner Should Know

4/22/2026

Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) Tax Benefits Explained

Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) Tax Benefits Explained Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) Tax Benefits Explained Key Takeaways How Are LLPs Taxed in the UK? 5 Tax Benefits of an Limited Liability Partnership 1. No Entity Level Tax on Trading Profits 2. Flexible Profit Sharing Between Members 3. Potential National Insurance Savings Illustrative example: NIC on £100,000 of profits or salary (2025/26) 4. A More Straightforward Route to Admitting New Equity Participants 5. Access to Partnership Loss Relief Conclusion Note This article covers direct taxes only and does not address VAT or other transaction taxes. Limited Liability Partnership, or LLP, is a business structure that enables its members the benefit of limited liability while being treated as a partnership for tax purposes. This means each member’s personal assets are protected from the debts and liabilities of the business, in the same way as a shareholder in a limited company. It is a popular choice for professional services firms, consultancies, and other businesses where owners want to share profits directly rather than through a company and dividend structure. This article explains how LLP taxation works, sets out five key tax benefits of the LLP structure, and highlights the key issues business owners should consider in practice. Tax transparent – no corporation tax on LLP trading profits; taxed once on the individual partners Flexible profit sharing without restructuring share capital Members are taxed on profits as they arise, whether drawn or not Professional advice is essential – salaried member rules, loss relief restrictions and other factors can change the picture significantly Where an LLP carries on a trade, profession or business with a view to profit, HMRC treats it as tax transparent. That means the LLP is not normally taxed on its trading profits. Instead, the profits are allocated to the members, who are taxed personally on their respective shares. The LLP does, however, have compliance obligations. If HMRC issues a notice requiring a partnership return, the LLP must file a partnership tax return (form SA800) setting out the partnership’s income and how profits have been allocated among the members. In practice, active LLPs will ordinarily be required to file an SA800. Each member is then assessed on their share of the profits and must file their own tax return or, if a member is a company, account for its share under the corporation tax rules. Additionally, the LLP must file a confirmation statement and annual accounts with Companies House. The table below sets out how income is taxed in each structure. LLP Member Limited Company Who pays tax on profits? The individual member, through self-assessment The company pays corporation tax; shareholders pay further tax on extraction Tax on trading profits Income tax at 20%, 40% or 45% on the member’s share (England, Wales and Northern Ireland; different rates apply in Scotland) Corporation tax : 19% small profits rate (profits up to £50,000), 25% main rate (profits over £250,000), with marginal relief in between Tax on profit extraction No further charge Dividends are taxed at income tax rates of 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35% National Insurance Class 4 NIC is charged on tax-adjusted trading profits from self-employment: 6% on profits between £12,570 and £50,270, then 2% above £50,270 Class 1 employee NIC is charged on earnings, such as salary and bonuses: 8% between £12,570 and £50,270, then 2% above £50,270, while dividends are not subject to NIC Employer NIC None Employer NIC is charged at 15% on all employee earnings above the secondary threshold of £5,000 per year Class 2 NIC No longer payable for most self-employed individuals from 2024/25; voluntary contributions may be made where profits are below £6,845 and the individual wants to protect their state pension record Not applicable Dividend tax rates from 6 April 2026 From 6 April 2026, the ordinary rate of dividend tax increased from 8.75% to 10.75%, and the higher rate from 33.75% to 35.75%. The additional rate remains at 39.35%. This change increases the cost of extracting profits from a limited company through dividends. Important LLP members are taxed on their allocated share of profits, whether or not those profits are drawn out of the business. This means a partner may have a tax liability that is higher than the cash they have actually received in the year. It is important to plan for this and ensure sufficient funds are set aside to meet tax payments when they fall due. As explained in Section 2, LLP profits are taxed once, on the individual members. There is no separate charge on the entity level. A limited company, by contrast, faces two layers of tax. The company first pays corporation tax on its profits at rates between 19% and 25% (with marginal relief for profits between £50,000 and £250,000). If those after-tax profits are then extracted as dividends, the shareholders pay a further income tax charge on the dividend. In an LLP, there is no second layer. An LLP offers much more flexibility in how profits are shared between members than a company structure. Members’ share of the profits is set out in the LLP agreement, not fixed by share capital. This makes it easier to reflect different levels of contribution, seniority or performance. The allocation can be changed from year to year without restructuring share capital. From a tax perspective, this flexibility means that profit allocations can follow genuine commercial arrangements in a way that is more difficult to achieve in a company, where dividends must be paid in proportion to shareholding unless different share classes are created, which involves more formality and cost. Note In an LLP, profit allocations must reflect genuine commercial arrangements. HMRC’s mixed member rules can apply where profits are shifted to a corporate member to gain a tax advantage. The rules target cases where profits are diverted beyond a fair commercial return or where losses are allocated to individuals to access relief. Where the rules apply, HMRC can reallocate profit to individual members or restrict loss relief. An LLP member is treated as self-employed for tax purposes rather than as an employee. As a result, the LLP does not operate PAYE on the member’s profit share and does not incur employer’s National Insurance on those amounts. Instead, the member accounts for income tax and Class 4 NIC through self-assessment . By contrast, salary or other employment income paid to an employee or director of a limited company is subject to PAYE, employee’s Class 1 NIC and employer’s Class 1 NIC. The difference is therefore not only the absence of employer’s NIC at the LLP level, but also that the individual member is subject to a different NIC regime from an employee. This can produce a meaningfully lower NIC cost and potential savings compared with an employment model. The table below compares the NIC and related reporting obligations for a limited company and an LLP. Charge Limited Company (employee/director) LLP (self-employed partner) Employer NIC 15% on earnings above £5,000 per year N/A Employee NIC / Class 4 NIC Class 1: 8% on earnings £12,570 to £50,270, then 2% above Class 4: 6% on tax-adjusted trading profits £12,570 to £50,270, then 2% above Class 1A NIC on benefits in kind 15% of the taxable value of benefits provided to employees N/A P11D reporting Required for reportable benefits N/A This comparison assumes the company employee receives the full £100,000 as salary. In practice, many company directors take a mix of salary and dividends, which would reduce the NIC cost on the company side. The comparison is intended to show the difference in NIC treatment on the same amount of income. NIC Element Company Employee LLP Partner Employer NIC (15% on earnings above £5,000) £14,250.00 Nil Employee Class 1 NIC £4,010.60 N/A Class 4 NIC N/A £3,256.60 Class 1A NIC on benefits Depends on benefits provided Nil Total NIC cost (excluding benefits) £18,260.60 £3,256.60 In a limited company, admitting a new shareholder involves issuing or transferring shares. That process requires a valuation of the shares, updates to the share register, filings at Companies House, and potentially stamp duty on the transfer. If shares are issued to an employee or director at less than market value, the discount may be taxed as employment income. The administrative and professional costs of these steps can be a real barrier, particularly for smaller businesses. In an LLP, the position is more straightforward. Adding a new member involves amending the LLP agreement, which is a private document between the members. There is no share capital to adjust, no requirement to have the business valued for the purpose of the admission, and no stamp duty on the admission (unlike a share transfer in a company, which can trigger stamp duty at 0.5% of the consideration paid). However, where an LLP holds land or property, changes in members’ interests can give rise to an SDLT charge based on the proportion of the underlying property’s market value. The new member then begins to participate in profits on the terms agreed by the partners. Adjusting profit shares or retiring existing members follows the same flexible process. From a tax perspective, admitting a new LLP member does not create the same valuation and reporting issues that arise when shares change hands in a company. This makes it a more practical and cost-effective route to shared ownership. This benefit is particularly relevant for professional services firms and early-stage businesses Because an LLP is taxed as a partnership, an individual partner may be able to claim relief for their share of the LLP’s trading losses. This is a real advantage over a limited company, where losses stay with the company and do not reduce a shareholder’s personal tax bill. The main routes for claiming relief are: Sideways relief: setting the loss against general income of the same tax year or the previous tax year. Early year relief: for losses arising in the first four tax years in which the member carries on the trade or profession through the LLP, the loss can be carried back against income of the three tax years before the loss-making year. Carry forward: losses can be carried forward to set against future profits of the same trade. There are, however, some important restrictions on the amount of relief a member can claim against other income. Capital contribution limit: Where an LLP carries on a trade, the amount of loss that a member can set against other income or chargeable gains is limited to the capital they have contributed to the LLP. For example, if a member has contributed £20,000 of capital, they can only claim up to £20,000 of sideways relief, even if their share of the loss is higher. Any excess can still be carried forward against future profits of the same trade. Non-active member restriction: Members who spend less than 10 hours a week on average working in the trade are treated as non-active. Non-active members face an additional cap of £25,000 per year on sideways relief. General income tax relief restriction: There is also a general cap that limits the total amount of certain income tax reliefs an individual can claim in any one year. The cap is the greater of £50,000 and 25% of the individual’s adjusted total income. None of these restrictions applies to losses carried forward against future profits of the same trade. They only limit the ability to set losses against other sources of income or gains. Important The benefits described above assume the LLP member is a genuine self-employed partner. The salaried member rules, introduced in 2014, can treat an LLP member as an employee for income tax and NIC purposes if all three of the following conditions are met. Condition A: at least 80% of the member’s total pay is fixed and does not vary by reference to the LLP’s overall profits. Condition B: the member does not have significant influence over the affairs of the LLP. Condition C: the member’s capital contribution is less than 25% of their expected fixed pay. If all three conditions are met, the LLP must operate PAYE and pay employer NIC on that member’s remuneration, and several of the benefits described above will not be available. To preserve self-employed treatment, a member needs to fail at least one condition. The analysis is fact-sensitive, and HMRC actively monitors compliance. Any LLP with a mix of senior and junior members should review whether these rules apply to each individual. The Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) remains a strong option for many UK businesses. Tax transparency, flexible profit sharing, NIC savings, a simpler route to admitting new equity participants, and access to partnership loss relief can all deliver real financial advantages. This is particularly relevant for professional services firms and businesses where the partners intend to draw most of their profits. File your LLP with Expert Accountants to ensure complete compliance Get professional Support Flexible Profit Sharing Between Members llp-and-taxation-benefits llp and taxation benefits page Page

Relevant Life Plan

4/21/2026

Complete Guide to Relevant Life Plans for UK Directors and Employees

Complete Guide to Relevant Life Plans for UK Directors and Employees Complete Guide to Relevant Life Plans for UK Directors and Employees What Is a Relevant Life Plan in the UK? How the UK Relevant Life Plan Usually Works in Practice Main Tax Position for the Company and for the Employee Inheritance Tax: What the Trust Means in Practice (And the Two Charges People Miss) 1) The “ten-year anniversary” charge 2) The “exit” charge when money leaves the trust The practical takeaway The Conditions the Relevant Life Policy Needs to Satisfy When the Relevant Life Plan Expected Tax Treatment Can Go Wrong Salary sacrifices and cash alternatives The company can benefit from the proceeds The cover level is hard to justify The trust and policy paperwork do not match The policy includes the wrong type of benefit What Happens to Relevant Life Plan if the Employee Leaves or Retires Practical checks before putting a Relevant Life Plan in place Summary Do you have more queries? A relevant life plan is an employer-arranged life policy that can provide death-in-service style cover for an individual employee. It is often used by smaller companies where cover is needed for a director or another employee, but it is not simply a personal life insurance policy paid for by the company. The tax treatment depends on how the policy is structured, who can benefit from it, and whether it is genuinely being provided as an employee benefit. This article explains what a relevant life plan is, how it normally works, and the main UK tax points for both the employer and the employee. It also highlights the common situations where the expected tax treatment may not apply. Relevant life plans are often used where a company wants to provide death-in-service style cover for a particular employee without putting in place a group life arrangement for a wider employee group. That can make them especially useful for smaller businesses, owner-managed companies and family companies, where the employer may want to cover a director or another employee on an individual basis rather than through a broader scheme. They can also be attractive where the company wants to pay for the cover itself instead of increasing salary and leaving the employee to arrange personal life insurance from net income. That can work well in practice, but the tax position still depends on the facts. In particular, the company should be able to show that the premium is being paid as part of a genuine employment package for business purposes, rather than as private family cover paid through the company. HMRC’s approach is not automatic and becomes more difficult where there is a personal motive or the overall package looks excessive for the role. Another practical point is that, when structured properly, a relevant life plan sits outside the registered pension scheme regime . In other words, it is not simply another registered pension death benefit. Instead, it has its own statutory conditions, including rules on who can benefit and the type of policy that can qualify. In a typical relevant life plan, the employer puts the cover in place and pays the premiums. The employee is the person whose life is insured. The insurance company provides the policy and pays the claim if the policy terms are met. If the employee dies while the cover is in force and the claim is accepted, the insurance company will usually pay the lump sum to the trustees. The trustees then distribute the money to the beneficiaries in line with the trust terms and any nomination the employee has made. The company is not intended to receive the pay-out. There are therefore usually five parties involved: the employer, the employee, the insurance company, the trustees and the beneficiaries. This is why a relevant life plan should not be confused with business protection cover. Business protection is designed to benefit the business or its owners. A relevant life plan is designed to provide a personal death benefit for the employee’s intended beneficiaries. From the company’s point of view, there are usually two main tax questions. The first is whether paying the premium creates a taxable benefit for the employee. Where a relevant life plan is structured as a qualifying relevant life policy, the death benefit element can usually fall outside the normal benefits code. That is one reason these plans are often used by smaller companies. However, that treatment should not be assumed just because the policy is described as life cover. The detail still matters. Problems are more likely where the policy includes non-qualifying features, where the company or its owners could benefit from the payout, or where the arrangement looks more like private cover being paid through the business than a genuine employee benefit. The second is whether the company can deduct the premium for Corporation Tax. This is a question of fact and degree, not an automatic relief. In many straightforward cases, the premium can be deductible where the cover forms part of a genuine remuneration package and the cost is incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade. HMRC’s focus is on the overall package, not just the premium on its own. A challenge is more likely where there is a personal or non-business motive, where the level of cover appears excessive for the role, or where the arrangement is being used in a way that suggests tax planning rather than ordinary commercial reward. That can be especially relevant in owner-managed and single-director companies, where the business should keep a clear record of why the cover was provided and how the level of cover was decided. Update 05/11/2026 The Autumn Budget on 28/10/2026 did not change the relevant life policy rules. The main rate of Corporation Tax remains 25%, and employer Class 1 National Insurance of 15% above the £5,000 secondary threshold is relevant where the optional remuneration rules apply. For the employee, the starting point is usually whether the company paying the premium creates an annual tax charge. Where a relevant life plan is structured in the usual way, the employee will often not face an annual income tax charge purely because the employer pays the premium. HMRC says that provision for a death benefit can fall outside the normal benefits code in the right circumstances, but that only applies to the specific exemption in section 307 ITEPA 2003 and should not be treated as automatic. The position needs more care in two situations. The first is where the employee gives up salary or bonus in return for the benefit, or can choose cash instead. In that case, HMRC’s optional remuneration arrangement rules may apply. Those rules are in section 69A ITEPA 2003, and they can mean the employee is taxed on the higher of the cash forgone and the normal taxable value of the benefit. HMRC says the protection preserved for death benefits under a registered pension scheme does not apply in the same way to a relevant life plan, because relevant life cover sits outside the registered pension scheme regime. The second is where the policy includes features that go beyond the qualifying death cover itself. The exemption in section 307 applies to the cost of providing the qualifying death-benefit element. It does not automatically extend to ancillary benefits, non-death features or investment-type elements attached to the same policy. HMRC says that if part of a policy qualifies and part does not, the exemption only works if the qualifying part and its cost can be identified separately. If they cannot be separated, the mixed cost is not covered by the exemption. The other key issue is what happens if the employee dies while the policy is in force. HMRC says that a payment from an employer’s life policy would normally fall within the employer-financed retirement benefits scheme framework, usually shortened to EFRBS, but a payment from a properly structured relevant life policy is excluded from that charge. For that treatment to hold, the policy must satisfy the statutory conditions. In broad terms, it must be a policy on the death of a single individual, payable before a specified age not exceeding 75, with no surrender value, with the benefits ultimately restricted to individuals or charities, and without a main tax avoidance purpose. In practice, families also focus on the trust arrangement. HMRC recognises that these policies are often held in a discretionary trust, so that the proceeds are paid to trustees who then distribute them for the benefit of the intended beneficiaries. That structure helps keep the company from benefiting from the pay-out and can make the payment process more straightforward after a claim, but the outcome still depends on the policy terms, the trust deed and the trustees acting within those terms. A key reason relevant life plans are usually written into trust is that, if the arrangement is set up properly, the death benefit can usually be paid outside the employee’s personal estate. In practice, the policy is often held in a discretionary trust, with the insurance proceeds paid to the trustees and then distributed to the intended beneficiaries under the trust terms. HMRC also recognises that relevant life policies are often held through a discretionary trust. That does not mean the trust is ignored for Inheritance Tax . A discretionary trust is usually within the relevant property regime, which means there can be 10-year anniversary charges and exit charges. In many straightforward relevant life cases, those charges may still be nil in practice, but it is worth understanding why. HMRC says most property held in trust is relevant property, that a 10-year charge can arise if relevant property above the threshold is held at the anniversary date, and that exit charges can apply when relevant property leaves the trust. A common misunderstanding is that premiums paid into a relevant life plan create a growing cash fund inside the trust. Usually they do not. In a typical term assurance arrangement, the trust holds the policy itself rather than an accumulating pot of money. HMRC says a term assurance policy will not have a surrender value, although it may still have an open market value. So, while the employee is alive, there is often little or no practical value in the trust unless and until a claim is paid. The 10-year anniversary charge becomes relevant only if the trust is holding relevant property with value at the 10-year point. In many ordinary relevant life cases, there may be no claim proceeds in the trust at that stage, so no charge arises in practice. The position can be different if the trustees have already received a death benefit and are still holding that money when the anniversary date arrives. HMRC says the charge is based on the net value of the relevant property in the trust on the day before the 10-year anniversary. An exit charge can arise when relevant property leaves the trust, for example when trustees distribute funds to beneficiaries. HMRC says this charge can apply at up to 6%, although the calculation depends on the facts and there are cases where no exit charge arises. In a straightforward term policy case, the position is often simpler because the policy usually had no surrender value before the claim, but unusual facts still need care. For most families, the trust is there to direct the proceeds to the right people, not to hold large sums indefinitely. A clean way to describe the position is that the trust often holds a policy with no surrender value while the employee is alive, and that any trust tax exposure becomes more relevant if claim proceeds are later paid into the trust and retained there. A relevant life plan is not just any life policy paid for by an employer. The legislation links the definition to the rules for excepted group life policies, adapted for a single life. In broad terms, the policy needs to stay within a fairly narrow framework. The main conditions are usually as follows: The benefit must be a death benefit on the life of a single individual The policy must only pay on death before a specified age, and that age cannot be more than 75 It should not build up a surrender value. If the policy is cancelled, there should usually be no surrender value, apart from a possible refund of premiums in limited circumstances. The payout must be set up for individuals or charities, not for the company. This can be done directly, but it is often done through a trust where trustees receive the money and pass it on. The arrangement must be set up for genuine protection, not mainly to get a tax advantage. That is why a policy with an investment element, a real cash value, or the wrong beneficiary structure can cause problems. It is also why additional features need to be checked carefully. Some add-ons may be fine, but you should not assume that every added feature keeps the plan within the relevant life rules. The most common problem areas are practical rather than theoretical. This is one of the main watch points. If the employee gives up salary or bonus in return for the cover, or can choose cash instead of the benefit, the arrangement may fall within HMRC’s optional remuneration arrangement rules. In that case, the tax result can change significantly. HMRC says death benefits are not protected under these rules in the same way as retirement benefits, so the usual exemption under section 307 ITEPA 2003 may no longer help. In broad terms, the employee can then be taxed on the higher of the cash given up and the normal taxable value of the benefit. If that happens, the employer may need to report the benefit to HMRC and may also have to pay extra employer National Insurance . In practice, that is often dealt with through payroll or through the P11D process . A relevant life plan is meant to support the employee’s family or other permitted beneficiaries. If the business can receive the pay-out, directly or indirectly, the arrangement starts to look more like business protection than an employee benefit. HMRC says a relevant life policy is excluded from the EFRBS charge only if it meets the statutory conditions, and those conditions are built around benefits for individuals or charities rather than the employer. A high level of cover is not automatically wrong, but it does increase risk in owner-managed companies. HMRC’s approach to Corporation Tax relief focuses on whether the overall remuneration package is incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade, and HMRC may challenge cases where the package looks excessive for the work done or has a personal motive. These plans rely on the legal documents doing what everyone thinks they do. If the trust is not completed correctly, trustee details are wrong, or the beneficiary position is unclear, the arrangement becomes much harder to support and can create delays or disputes when a claim is made. The tax outcome depends on the policy and trust actually matching the intended structure. A plan designed as straightforward death cover becomes harder to analyse if it also includes non-qualifying elements. HMRC says that where part of a life assurance policy qualifies for section 307 and part does not, the exemption only works if the qualifying part and its cost can be identified separately. If they cannot be separated, the mixed cost is not covered by the exemption. A relevant life plan is usually set up as an employee benefit, so it should be reviewed whenever employment changes. If the employee leaves the company, the most common outcome is that the company stops paying the premiums and the cover ends. The employee may then decide whether to arrange personal cover separately. In some cases, a policy may be capable of being continued, assigned or replaced, but that should never be treated as automatic. Any change in who owns the policy, who pays for it or who is entitled to the benefit can affect both the practical position and the tax analysis. HMRC’s guidance also distinguishes between assignments for money or money’s worth and assignments that are not, so this is an area that needs checking rather than assumption. A review is also sensible as the insured person approaches the policy end age. Relevant life cover is normally designed to end before age 75, so it is not intended to continue indefinitely into later life. If cover is still needed after that point, a different arrangement may be required. Any change in employment status is a good time to review three things together: whether the cover should continue, stop or be replaced whether the trust still directs the benefit to the right people whether the tax position still looks as expected In practice, many problems can be avoided by checking a short list before the policy goes live: confirm the company is arranging death cover as an employee benefit, not business protection confirm the beneficiaries are individuals or charities, usually through a trust confirm the policy ends before the insured reaches age 75 and has no surrender value check whether there is any salary sacrifice, flexible benefits choice or cash alternative keep a short note on file showing why the level of cover is commercially reasonable keep the policy schedule and trust deed together and review them when employment changes A relevant life plan can be a practical way for a company to provide death-in-service style cover for an individual employee, often a director, but only if the structure is right. The expected tax treatment does not come from the product label alone. It depends on the policy meeting the statutory relevant life conditions and being used as a genuine employee benefit rather than as business protection or private cover routed through the company. This article is intended as general information only and does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice. The tax treatment of relevant life plans depends on individual circumstances. You should take professional advice before putting a plan in place or relying on any of the points discussed above. We, at UK Property Accountants have helped a lot of clients deal with Relevant Life Plan in an efficient way. If you have any queries on tax enquiries or need some advice from us. Drop Your Queries What a relevant life plan is relevant-life-plans-explained-hmrc-rules-tax-benefits relevant life plans explained hmrc rules tax benefits page Page

A group of professionals discussing a commercial property strategy over a model.

3/10/2026

Commercial Property Strategy for Business Owners: A Practical SSAS Route

Commercial Property Strategy for Business Owners: A Practical SSAS Route Commercial Property Strategy for Business Owners: A Practical SSAS Route Key Takeaways 1. The Opportunity: Turning Rent into Retirement Value Leasing vs SSAS Ownership (Illustrative Only) 2. What Is a SSAS? 3. Why a SSAS Works for Commercial Property Owners 4. Setting Up the Structure Buying Property from a Connected Party (If Relevant to You) 5. Funding the SSAS Employer Contributions (Usually the Primary Route) Personal Contributions Salary Sacrifice Transfers from Existing Pensions Annual Allowance and Carry Forward Other Constraints on Contributions 6. Worked Funding Examples (Illustrative) 7. Exit Scenario: Selling the Property Conclusion Frequently Asked Questions Is there a limit when the SSAS lends to the sponsoring employer? Can I set up a SSAS if I already have a personal pension or SIPP? What happens if I die before I take benefits? What ongoing costs should I expect? A SSAS can buy and hold your commercial premises, with rental income and capital gains tax-free within the scheme The company’s contributions to fund the purchase are deductible for corporation tax and free of NIC With carry forward and scheme borrowing, many businesses can reach their target purchase price sooner than expected Commercial property focus: investing in residential or mixed-use property can trigger severe tax charges If you run an owner-managed business from commercial premises, there is a good chance that rent leaves your company's bank account every month and goes to a third-party landlord. That payment may be commercially necessary, but it does not build a long-term asset for you. Now consider an alternative: the business still pays market rent, but the landlord is your own pension scheme. The pension scheme owns the premises, and the rent becomes pension investment income rather than money leaving your orbit entirely. This is a well-established planning structure commonly used by owner-managed businesses across the UK. The vehicle that makes it possible is a Small Self-Administered Scheme, or SSAS. Yes, leasing from a third party can sometimes be the better answer. It can offer flexibility, avoid tying up capital and suit businesses with short-term or uncertain premises needs. But where the need for space is long-term, and the business is profitable, a SSAS can turn a recurring cost into a retirement asset. The rest of this article explores how. Scenario A: Lease from a Third Party Scenario B: SSAS Owns the Premises Rent (example) £30,000 per year to a landlord £30,000 per year (market rent) paid to the SSAS 10-year rent total £300,000 paid out with no assets to show for it £300,000 received by the SSAS, accumulating tax-free within the scheme What you have at year 10 No premises asset in your structure The SSAS still owns the property, and the rent has built up inside the scheme Corporation Tax position on rent paid Rent deductible (same either way) Rent deductible (same either way) Corporation Tax saving on contributions Not applicable Employer contributions used to fund the purchase are deductible, generating corporation tax savings .tx-ssas-lease .tx-ssas-lease-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-lease table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-lease th,.tx-ssas-lease td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left;vertical-align:top}.tx-ssas-lease th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} What if You Want to Let to Third Party Tenants Instead? A SSAS can also be a useful route for individuals who simply want to become landlords of commercial property. The comparison above may not apply in that scenario, but the tax advantages of holding property inside the scheme still do: rental income is received free of income tax and gains on disposal are exempt from CGT. A Small Self-Administered Scheme (SSAS) is a trust-based occupational pension scheme set up by a sponsoring employer (usually a limited company) and registered with HMRC. Members are typically directors and key employees, and, in most cases, the members also act as trustees, giving them direct involvement in investment decisions. Membership is commonly small. HMRC describes a SSAS as being available for up to 12 members. A SSAS is treated as an Investment-regulated Pension Schemes (IRPS) because members can influence how the fund is invested. That classification matters because the IRPS taxable property rules apply: if the scheme invests in residential property or certain tangible moveable property (such as art, antiques, or classic cars), an unauthorised payment charge of up to 40% can arise on the member, with a further 40% scheme sanction charge on any gain on disposal. Commercial property and investment-grade gold bullion are permitted investments and do not trigger these charges. Members carry the legal responsibilities of acting as trustees, including compliance with pension laws and HMRC reporting. For a broader overview of SSAS mechanics, trustee duties and investment options, check out: A Complete Guide to SSAS Pension Scheme in the UK. A SSAS is attractive for commercial property planning because it combines direct ownership, lease flexibility and pension tax treatment. Feature How It Works Direct ownership The SSAS trustees can buy and hold commercial premises as a scheme investment. Lease to your company or third parties Your trading company, another group entity, or an unconnected tenant can lease the property from the SSAS at market rent under a formal lease. Rent treatment The tenant’s rent is a business cost. Where it meets the wholly and exclusively test (meaning the expense is incurred entirely for the purposes of the trade, with no other purpose), it is normally deductible for corporation tax. The SSAS receives the rent free of income tax. Tax treatment inside the scheme Investment income within the scheme is exempt from income tax, and gains on disposal of scheme investments are exempt from CGT (subject to the taxable property rules noted in Section 2). Sale proceeds remain in the scheme If the SSAS sells the property, the proceeds stay within the pension scheme for reinvestment or to support future benefits. Borrowing power The SSAS can borrow from a commercial lender. Authorised borrowing is capped at 50% of the scheme’s net assets (the total value of the scheme’s assets, less any outstanding liabilities) immediately before the borrowing is drawn. .tx-ssas-feat .tx-ssas-feat-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-feat table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-feat th,.tx-ssas-feat td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left;vertical-align:top}.tx-ssas-feat th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} For many owner-managed businesses, the core idea is straightforward: the company continues to pay market rent, but the rent is paid into their own pension scheme, and the property is held as a long-term pension asset. If you do not yet have a company or a SSAS, here is the typical pathway. Step 1 - Incorporate a Company You will need a limited company to act as the sponsoring employer. Early decisions include: What the company will do (trading business, investment activity, or both). Who will be the directors and shareholders, and whether you will operate payroll. How you will fund the company initially (for example, share capital or a director’s loan account). Injecting funds into the company is not the same as funding the SSAS. Employer pension contributions are made by the company to the scheme, and the company needs to generate profits (or have sufficient trading resources) before those contributions become meaningful and defensible under the wholly and exclusively test. Timing and Planning Note A contribution must be physically paid to the SSAS within the corporation tax accounting period for the deduction to fall in that year. Where the company is funded initially through a director’s loan account, the subsequent extraction of profits (salary, dividends, pension contributions) should be planned as a coherent remuneration strategy rather than treated as separate decisions. Step 2 - Establish and Register the SSAS A trust deed and rules are put in place. Trustees are normally appointed from the members themselves, often alongside a professional trustee which most SSAS providers require as a condition of their service. A scheme administrator is appointed for HMRC purposes. This is a statutory role under the Finance Act 2004, responsible for registering the scheme, reporting to HMRC and ensuring compliance. The scheme is registered with HMRC to obtain a Pension Scheme Tax Reference (PSTR). Where required (most schemes with more than one member), the scheme is also registered with The Pensions Regulator. In practice, providers typically require trustees to be aged 18 or over. Step 3 - Open the SSAS Bank Account A dedicated bank account is opened in the name of the scheme trustees. This is often the practical bottleneck, as identity verification and bank processing can take time, often running in parallel with HMRC registration. You can set up more than one account if needed (for example, to separate contribution receipts from investment income). Not every property purchase involves a connected party, but many do. If you already own commercial premises personally, or your company (or another group entity) owns the property, you can sell it into the SSAS. This is a common and legitimate route, but it comes with additional requirements. Requirement What It Means Open market value sale The SSAS should buy at open market value, supported by an independent valuation. Personally owned property is normally acquired by sale rather than as an in-specie pension contribution. Tax on the seller The seller (individual or company) is treated as disposing of the property at market value and may face a tax charge. For individuals, CGT on non-residential property is charged at 18% (basic rate) or 24% (higher/additional rate) for 2025/26. For companies, chargeable gains are subject to corporation tax at 19% (profits up to £50,000), 25% (profits over £250,000), with marginal relief applying for profits between those thresholds. SDLT, LTT or LBTT The property will be subject to Stamp Duty Land Tax (England and Northern Ireland), Land Transaction Tax (Wales) or Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland). VAT and option to tax If the seller has opted to tax the property for VAT purposes, VAT at 20% will be charged on the purchase price. The SSAS can only recover that VAT if it is itself VAT-registered and opts to tax the property. Alternatively, if the transaction qualifies as a transfer of a going concern (TOGC), no VAT is charged at all. Specialist VAT advice is usually essential. Separate advice and documentation Connected transactions need particularly careful paperwork: valuation reports, lease terms, trustee minutes and appropriate legal representation on both sides. .tx-ssas-conn .tx-ssas-conn-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-conn table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-conn th,.tx-ssas-conn td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left;vertical-align:top}.tx-ssas-conn th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} Connected party purchases are also where the taxable property rules require particular attention. If any part of a building is residential or otherwise treated as taxable property, the tax consequences can be severe (see Section 2 for the charges that apply). Separate Legal Representation Where the SSAS is buying property from a connected party (including from you personally or from your company), the SSAS trustees should instruct their own solicitors, independent of the seller’s solicitors. This protects the trustees, ensures the transaction is documented on arm’s length terms and reduces the risk of challenge from HMRC. How quickly you can buy a property depends on how quickly the SSAS can build a fund, and whether you will use transfers or borrowing alongside contributions. In most owner-managed businesses, the company funds the SSAS through employer contributions: The contribution is deductible for corporation tax if it is incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade. No employer or employee National Insurance is due on an employer pension contribution. For corporation tax purposes, the deduction normally follows the period in which the contribution is actually paid. Members can also make personal contributions. Key points: Most SSASs operate the net pay arrangement, meaning contributions are deducted from gross pay before income tax. Higher and additional rate taxpayers receive full relief through the payroll without a separate self-assessment claim. They are less common in a SSAS context because employer contributions are usually more tax efficient, but they can be relevant where the employer’s ability to contribute is limited. A salary sacrifice arrangement can be used alongside a SSAS. Under this approach, the member agrees to give up a portion of future salary in exchange for an equivalent employer pension contribution. The main advantage is that both employer and employee National Insurance savings arise on the sacrificed amount, making the overall cost of funding the pension lower than a straightforward employee contribution. Important: Autumn Budget 2025 Update The government has introduced the National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill, which proposes that from 6 April 2029, only the first £2,000 per individual per tax year of pension contributions made via salary sacrifice will remain exempt from National Insurance. Both employer and employee NIC will apply to any salary sacrifice above that threshold. The Bill is still before Parliament and has not yet received Royal Assent. Key points of caution The sacrifice must be a genuine contractual change, agreed in advance and documented properly. The reduced salary must not fall below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage. It may affect entitlement to state benefits and statutory payments calculated by reference to earnings. Salary sacrifice does not reduce the pension input amount for annual allowance purposes; the employer contribution is still tested against the annual allowance. Existing pension funds held in other registered pension schemes can be transferred into the SSAS, including workplace pensions, personal pensions and SIPPs. Transfers are not new contributions, so they do not use the annual allowance. This can be a powerful way to accelerate funding. Where a defined benefit transfer exceeds £30,000, regulated financial advice is required by law. The standard annual allowance for 2025/26 is £60,000. This is the maximum pension saving (across all schemes) before an annual allowance tax charge can arise. Unused annual allowance from the previous three tax years can be carried forward, but only from years where the individual was a member of a registered pension scheme. If you have only just set up your SSAS and were not in any other scheme in the prior years, you will not have any carry forward available. This is one of the most important points for new arrangements, and it is worth checking at the outset. Constraint What It Means Tapered annual allowance If threshold income exceeds £200,000 and adjusted income exceeds £260,000, the annual allowance can reduce to a minimum of £10,000. Directors taking salary and dividends should check both thresholds carefully. Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA) If a member has already flexibly accessed defined contribution pension benefits (for example, income drawdown from another scheme), the MPAA can reduce the annual allowance for money purchase savings to £10,000. This should be checked at the outset. “Proportionate to profits” There is no statutory profit ratio rule. The corporation tax test is whether the contribution is incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade and is affordable and properly documented. A useful litmus test is whether the same amount would have been contributed for a third-party employee doing the same work. Spreading of corporation tax relief Where the total employer contributions in a period exceed £500,000, HMRC can require the corporation tax relief on the excess over £500,000 to be spread over multiple periods rather than taken all at once. Good documentation and a clear remuneration strategy are the best protection. .tx-ssas-cons .tx-ssas-cons-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-cons table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-cons th,.tx-ssas-cons td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left;vertical-align:top}.tx-ssas-cons th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} The examples below are simplified and assume no investment return and no transaction costs. They show mechanics and timescales, and do not constitute financial advice. Example 1: £200,000 Property, Single Director Assumptions: one member, no carry forward available, no transfers. Tax Year Employer Contribution Cumulative Fund 2025/26 £60,000 £60,000 2026/27 £60,000 £120,000 2027/28 £60,000 £180,000 2028/29 £20,000 (balance) £200,000 .tx-ssas-ex1 .tx-ssas-ex1-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-ex1 table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-ex1 th,.tx-ssas-ex1 td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left}.tx-ssas-ex1 th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} Without carry forward or transfers, funding £200,000 through a single member’s annual allowance typically takes three to four tax years. Borrowing can shorten the timetable: once the scheme holds £120,000 after Year 2, authorised borrowing of up to £60,000 could bring total purchasing power to £180,000. By Year 3, with £180,000 in the scheme and borrowing of up to £90,000, the £200,000 target is comfortably within reach. If carry forward is available (for example, the member was in another registered pension scheme in the previous three tax years), larger one-off funding may be possible within annual allowance limits, subject to company affordability and documentation. Example 2: £1,500,000 Property, Eleven Member SSAS Assumptions: eleven members, each with a £60,000 annual allowance, no carry forward, no transfers. Tax Year Total Employer Contribution Cumulative Fund 2025/26 £660,000 (£60,000 each) £660,000 2026/27 £660,000 (£60,000 each) £1,320,000 .tx-ssas-ex2 .tx-ssas-ex2-wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:16px 0 24px}.tx-ssas-ex2 table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-family:var(--tt-font-sans);color:var(--tt-color-fg)}.tx-ssas-ex2 th,.tx-ssas-ex2 td{border:1px solid var(--tt-color-border);padding:10px 14px;text-align:left}.tx-ssas-ex2 th{background:var(--tt-color-muted);font-weight:600} After two tax years, the scheme holds £1.32 million. The SSAS can borrow up to 50% of its net assets, so with borrowing of around £180,000, a £1.5 million purchase could be completed in year two. At this scale, contribution planning needs extra care. Total employer contributions exceeding £500,000 in a single period can bring the spreading of relief rules into play for corporation tax, and the funding strategy should be documented as part of a coherent remuneration and business plan. Governance Note Family members can be included as SSAS members if the sponsoring employer invites them to join the scheme and the provider’s requirements are met. This is common in family businesses. However, adding members solely to increase annual allowance capacity, with no genuine role in or connection to the business, carries risk. As with all aspects of the SSAS structure, the arrangement must be commercially justifiable. Contribution allocations should be documented with a clear rationale. If the SSAS sells the property, the proceeds remain within the pension scheme. Gains on disposals of scheme investments are exempt from CGT, and the proceeds can be reinvested or held on deposit. Tax is not eliminated permanently. Tax can arise when benefits are eventually paid to members under the pension rules. Up to 25% of the benefits crystallised can normally be taken as a tax-free pension commencement lump sum (subject to the lump sum allowance), with the balance taxed as pension income when drawn. Benefits can normally be accessed from the minimum pension age (currently 55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028 for most people). The advantage of the structure is the deferral and sheltering of tax during the accumulation phase. For many business owners, that deferral, combined with years of tax-free growth on rental income and capital appreciation, is where the real value lies. Approaching Retirement? A SSAS can be particularly attractive for directors in their late 50s or 60s. Corporation Tax deductible contributions going in, a period of tax-free rental income and growth, and then early access to benefits (including the 25% tax free lump sum) can compress the advantages into a shorter timeframe. It is also worth noting that from 6 April 2027, most unused pension funds and death benefits are expected to be brought within the scope of inheritance tax. This makes drawing benefits during your lifetime, rather than preserving the fund indefinitely, an increasingly important part of retirement planning. For the right business, a SSAS converts rent from an irrecoverable cost into a payment that builds a pension asset, with investment income and gains sheltered from tax along the way. It requires proper governance and careful documentation, but for businesses that meet those conditions, the benefits can be substantial. Given the scale of the decision, getting professional advice before committing to this structure is essential. Yes. A loan to the sponsoring employer is only an authorised employer loan if the amount (together with other outstanding employer loans) does not exceed 50% of the scheme’s net assets immediately before the loan is made. The loan must also be properly secured and meet specific repayment and interest rate requirements. Yes. You can be a member of more than one registered pension scheme at the same time. However, your annual allowance applies across all schemes combined. If you are contributing to both a personal pension and a SSAS, the total pension inputs (including employer contributions) must stay within your available annual allowance to avoid a tax charge. Existing funds in a personal pension or SIPP can also be transferred into the SSAS without using the annual allowance. A SSAS can pay authorised death benefits under the pension rules, and the tax treatment depends on the type of benefit and the circumstances. As noted earlier in this article, the inheritance tax treatment of unused pension funds and death benefits is changing from 6 April 2027, which may affect how you plan your benefits. This should be discussed with your adviser as part of your wider estate planning. A SSAS involves higher administration and professional costs than a standard workplace pension. Annual fees typically cover scheme administration, regulatory compliance, and where appointed, a professional trustee. Property transactions also involve costs such as legal fees, valuations, surveys and lending arrangement fees, though these would apply to any commercial property purchase regardless of whether it is made through a SSAS. The SSAS specific costs are the ongoing scheme administration and governance, which should be factored into the business case from the outset. commercial-property-strategy-for-business-owners-a-practical-ssas-route commercial property strategy for business owners a practical ssas route page Page

New Anti-Avoidance Rules for Share Exchanges and Reorganisations: Are You Prepared?

2/26/2026

New Anti-Avoidance Rules for Share Exchanges and Reorganisations: Are You Prepared?

New Anti-Avoidance Rules for Share Exchanges and Reorganisations: Are You Prepared? New Anti-Avoidance Rules for Share Exchanges and Reorganisations: Are You Prepared? How Does the Share Exchange Relief Work? The Anti-Avoidance Rule: What It Said Then and What It Says Now The Anti-Avoidance Rule What It Said Then and What It Says Now The Six Principal Changes 1. A different approach to “arrangements” 2. Bona fide commercial reasons: removed 3. “Reducing or avoiding”: a broader test 4. Wider powers, more proportionate response 5. The 5% safe harbour: removed 6. Per-person application At a Glance: Old Rules and New Rules Why Did HMRC Change the Rules? Do I Need HMRC Clearance? Transitional Provisions Practical Steps: Getting It Right Under the New Rules Frequently Asked Questions What happens if HMRC refuses clearance? What if the transaction is already in progress but has not yet completed? Does clearance confirm that the share exchange relief applies? Conclusion The Autumn Budget 2025 introduced fundamental changes to the anti-avoidance rules that apply to share exchanges and company reconstructions under the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 (TCGA 1992). With effect from 26 November 2025, HMRC has significantly broader powers to challenge transactions that include a tax avoidance element, and the consequences of a successful challenge are now more targeted. These changes, contained in Clauses 37 and 38 of Finance Bill 2025–26, affect anyone involved in selling a business for shares, inserting a holding company, restructuring a corporate group, or carrying out a scheme of reconstruction. This article explains how the share exchange relief works, what has changed in the anti-avoidance rules, how the revised clearance process operates, and what you should be thinking about if a share exchange or reorganisation is on the horizon. Note HMRC’s guidance on the revised rules is currently set out in an interim appendix (CG-APP19) pending Royal Assent of the Finance Bill. When shares in one company are exchanged for shares or loan notes in another, the transaction would normally be treated as a disposal for Capital Gains Tax (CGT) purposes, triggering an immediate tax charge. However, Sections 135 and 136 TCGA 1992 can treat the exchange as though no disposal has taken place. The original shares and the new shares are treated as the same asset. No CGT arises at the point of exchange. Instead, any gain is rolled over into the new shares or securities. Tax is only paid when those new shares are eventually sold. This is sometimes described informally as “rollover” treatment, and it exists because most share exchanges are paper-for-paper transactions where no cash changes hands. These rules are relevant to a wide range of commercial transactions, including business sales where the buyer issues its own shares as part of the consideration, corporate group reorganisations, demergers, and the insertion of a new holding company above an existing trading company. They are a routine and important part of business restructuring. For more details on how the relief works, see our guide, " Share for Share Exchange & HMRC Clearance: Tax Relief Guide " Key point The share exchange relief defers the gain. It does not exempt it. Tax becomes payable when the new shares are eventually sold. The anti-avoidance rules exist to prevent the relief from being used to achieve more than deferral. The rollover treatment described above is not unconditional. It has always been subject to anti-avoidance provisions designed to prevent the relief from being used as part of arrangements whose real purpose is to avoid or reduce tax. These provisions apply across several reliefs: Section 135 (share exchanges), Section 136 (schemes of reconstruction involving shareholders), Section 139(5) (schemes of reconstruction involving companies), and Sections 103G, 103H, and 103I (the equivalent reliefs for collective investment schemes). Under the rules that applied before 26 November 2025, the anti-avoidance provisions would be triggered where the following conditions were not satisfied: The exchange or reconstruction itself had to be carried out for bona fide commercial reasons, and It must not form part of a scheme or arrangements of which the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, was avoidance of a liability to capital gains tax or corporation tax. Two further features shaped how the old rule operated in practice. Shareholders holding 5% or less of any class of shares or debentures in the company being acquired were automatically outside its scope. And if HMRC succeeded in showing that the provision applied, the consequence was all-or-nothing: rollover relief was denied for the entire exchange and every shareholder involved, regardless of whether they had any part in the planning. From 26 November 2025, the framework is different. The bona fide commercial reasons test has been removed entirely. The anti-avoidance rule now applies where arrangements relating to the exchange or reconstruction have a main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of reducing or avoiding a liability to capital gains tax or corporation tax. The term “arrangements” is defined broadly to include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions, whether or not legally enforceable. The 5% minority shareholder protection has also been removed. And where the rule is triggered, HMRC can now make “just and reasonable” adjustments targeting only those shareholders who sought the advantage, rather than denying the relief outright for everyone. The following section explains each of these changes in detail. Under the old rules, courts interpreted the “arrangements” broadly. If the exchange sat within a large commercial deal, the entire deal was treated as the relevant arrangements. Because the tax planning was only a small part of that whole, it often did not amount to a “main purpose.” The new test applies to arrangements “relating to” the exchange. HMRC can now focus on the specific steps surrounding the share exchange. A transaction can be entirely commercial in its overall purpose and still face a challenge if it includes a specific arrangement, such as a bespoke share class or a particular form of consideration, designed to create a tax advantage. Under the old rules, the anti-avoidance provision did not apply only if the exchange was carried out for bona fide commercial reasons, and it did not form part of a scheme or arrangements with a main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of avoiding CGT or corporation tax on chargeable gains. That commercial reasons condition has been removed entirely. The sole question now is whether the relevant arrangements have a main purpose of reducing or avoiding a liability to tax on capital gains. HMRC’s interim guidance confirms, however, that mere deferral, which is the intended effect of the share exchange provisions, is not itself treated as avoidance. The old wording referred only to “avoidance” of tax. The new wording also catches arrangements whose purpose is to “reduce” a tax liability, widening the scope to capture a broader range of planning outcomes. The old all-or-nothing consequence sometimes discouraged HMRC from invoking the provision because of the collateral damage to innocent shareholders. HMRC can now make “such adjustments as are just and reasonable” to counteract the reduction or avoidance. In practice, this means HMRC can tax only the specific shareholders who sought a tax advantage, while leaving others unaffected. This modernisation aligns the share exchange rules with the approach taken in most contemporary targeted anti-avoidance rules (TAARs) found elsewhere in the tax code. CG-APP19: Worked example Two shareholders hold 40% each in a company being acquired. Employee shareholders hold the remaining 20%. One shareholder asks for payment in loan notes specifically to defer CGT until after emigrating from the UK. HMRC considers the anti-avoidance rule applies to that shareholder’s arrangements. The adjustment is to disapply rollover relief for that shareholder only. The other shareholder and the employee shareholders are unaffected. Shareholders holding 5% or less were previously automatically outside the scope. That protection has been removed. All shareholders are now within scope if they are part of arrangements with a tax avoidance purpose, including employee shareholders, passive minority investors, and family members with small stakes. The old rules applied to the exchange as a whole. The new rules apply individually to each person who has entered into the relevant arrangements. HMRC’s policy note states that the rule will “only apply to those persons who entered into such arrangements” and “will not apply to persons who did not benefit from the avoidance put in place.” .tx-cmp{border-radius:10px 10px 0 0}.tx-cmp th{background:var(--tt-color-primary)!important;text-align:center!important}.tx-cmp td{text-align:center!important;vertical-align:middle!important}.tx-cmp tbody td:first-child{background:color-mix(in srgb,var(--tt-color-primary) 12%,var(--tt-color-bg))!important}.tx-cmp tbody tr:nth-child(even) td:not(:first-child){background:var(--tt-color-bg)} Feature Before 26 November 2025 From 26 November 2025 Purpose test Exchange had to be “part of” arrangements with a main avoidance purpose. Purpose of the overall transaction was assessed. Test applies to arrangements “relating to” the exchange. HMRC can focus on specific steps. Commercial reasons Relief required the exchange to be carried out for bona fide commercial reasons (one of two conditions). The commercial purpose condition has been removed. The sole question is whether arrangements have a main purpose of reducing or avoiding tax. Consequence “All or nothing.” Relief denied for the entire exchange and all shareholders. “Just and reasonable” adjustments. HMRC targets only shareholders who sought the advantage. Minority shareholders 5% or less automatically outside scope. 5% safe harbour removed. All shareholders within scope if part of relevant arrangements. Counteraction method Relief simply disapplied for all parties. Adjustments via closure notices or discovery assessments. Full or partial disapplication as appropriate. The old wording created a gap. In several recent cases, HMRC attempted to use Section 137 to counteract tax planning incorporated into a larger commercial transaction. The courts held that the “arrangements” were the entire commercial deal, and the tax planning was not a “main purpose” of that whole. HMRC’s interim guidance at CG-APP19 identifies the principal cases: Delinian Limited v HMRC [2023] EWCA Civ 1281 and Olivia Wilkinson & Ors v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 695 (TC). HMRC’s policy note states that the revised rules will “better target those cases where, as part of a commercial exchange or company reconstruction, additional arrangements have been put in place to obtain a tax advantage.” For a detailed account of how the Tribunal reached its decision in Wilkinson, see our case study, " Wilkinson v HMRC: Smart Tax Planning or Tax Avoidance? " A statutory clearance can be requested under Section 138 TCGA 1992. It is optional, but it exists so that commercial decisions are not stalled by uncertainty about the anti-avoidance rule. Either the acquiring or the target company can apply with a written application containing full particulars of the operations to be carried out. HMRC must respond within 30 days, or within 30 days of receiving any further information requested. Two aspects of the clearance process have changed under the new rules: No fixed time limit on post-Budget clearances. Clearances under the revised rules remain valid provided the transaction is carried out as described, but any material change may invalidate the clearance. Changes require a new application. Any application received on or after 26 November 2025 will be assessed under the revised rules, even where it relates to a change to a previously cleared transaction. For a full explanation of the clearance process, see our guide, " Share for Share Exchange & HMRC Clearance: Tax Relief Guide ". Pre-Budget clearances: Valid only if the transaction completes by 26 January 2026. Otherwise, a new application under the revised rules is required. Pending applications (submitted before 26 November 2025): Considered under the old wording. If cleared, old rules apply if the transaction completes within 60 days of the clearance decision. Post-Budget clearances: No fixed time limit, but material changes to the facts may invalidate the clearance. The new rules do not prevent businesses from restructuring or selling. The share exchange provisions continue to work as intended for genuine commercial transactions. But they do change the risk profile where a transaction includes elements that could be characterised as tax motivated. 1 Step 1 - Understand the structure of your deal The rules are now more targeted, and the analysis is more step-by-step than it was under the old framework. Make sure you understand how the share exchange rules apply to your specific transaction before committing to a structure. 2 Step 2 - Ask whether each material step has a commercial reason A transaction can be 100% commercial in its overall purpose and still face a challenge if it includes a specific arrangement designed to create a tax advantage. Under the new rules, the analysis is more targeted, so the steps that drive the tax outcome need to be capable of being justified on their own merits. 3 Step 3 - Keep records at the time Contemporaneous documents carry far more weight than recollections after the event. Board minutes, heads of terms, investor communications and adviser correspondence should explain why each step exists. 4 Step 4 - Consider advance clearance early Given the wider scope of the new rules and the limited guidance on how HMRC will apply the “just and reasonable” adjustment power, it may be worth seeking clearance for any transaction that includes features which could attract scrutiny. The transaction can still proceed, but HMRC may open an enquiry and apply the anti-avoidance rule through a closure notice or discovery assessment. A refusal can be referred to the First Tier Tribunal within 30 days. The key date is when the new shares or securities are issued, not when the transaction was agreed. If the issue takes place on or after 26 November 2025, the revised rules apply. The transitional provisions may allow completion under the old rules, but only within the windows set out above. No. Clearance only confirms that HMRC will not invoke the anti-avoidance rule under Section 137. It does not confirm that the technical conditions for the relief under Section 135 or 136 are met, and it does not cover the wider tax analysis of the transaction. The changes discussed above are not minor technical amendments. They change the risk profile of share exchange planning and require careful consideration in any transaction involving the issue of new shares or securities on or after 26 November 2025. Need Help? Planning a sale, reorganisation, or holding company? Get the structure right from the start. CONTACT US The Anti-Avoidance Rule What It Said Then and What It Says Now - New Anti-Avoidance Rules anti-avoidance-rules-share-exchanges-and-reorganisations anti avoidance rules share exchanges and reorganisations page Page

Wilkinson v HMRC: Smart Tax Planning or Tax Avoidance?

2/26/2026

Wilkinson v HMRC: Difference Between Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance

Wilkinson v HMRC: Difference Between Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance Wilkinson v HMRC: Difference Between Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance Quick facts The Background The Transaction and the Tax Planning Why the Share Exchange Rules Mattered Section 135, explained simply Section 137, the anti-avoidance rule What HMRC Argued What the Tribunal Decided What This Means for Business Owners and Taxpayers The Rules Have Since Changed Need Advice on Capital Gains Tax Planning? When a family sells a business, it is natural to structure the deal in a way that keeps the tax bill as low as possible. But at what point does HMRC consider that the planning has gone too far? That was the central question in Olivia Wilkinson & Ors v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 695 (TC). It followed a £130 million sale of a private company, in which part of the sale structure was designed to enable the sellers’ daughters to benefit from Entrepreneurs’ Relief (now Business Asset Disposal Relief ). HMRC challenged the arrangements, arguing that the tax planning amounted to avoidance and should be blocked. The First Tier Tribunal ruled in favour of the family, finding that the tax planning was secondary to the commercial purpose of the sale. The anti-avoidance rules that applied in this case have since been amended by the Autumn Budget 2025, and the framework for share exchanges is now different in several important respects. Understanding how the Tribunal reached its decision in Wilkinson is a useful starting point for understanding what those changes are designed to address. Case: Olivia Wilkinson & Ors v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 695 (TC) Transaction: Sale of Paragon Automotive Limited (P Ltd) for £130 million Key issue: Could HMRC block the normal tax deferral on the share exchange because the family’s arrangements included tax planning? Outcome: The family won. The Tribunal found that avoiding CGT was not the main purpose of the overall arrangements. Paragon Automotive Limited (P Ltd) was a private company providing logistics and vehicle processing services to the automotive sector. Robert Wilkinson was the lead entrepreneur behind the business from its founding in 2005. Together with his wife, Susan, he held around 58% of the shares. The remaining 42% was held by a separate group of minority shareholders. In June 2016, an opportunity arose to sell the company to TF1 Ltd (the buying company), a subsidiary of the BCA Trading group, an established operator in the same sector. The deal moved quickly. Within about 4 weeks, the parties agreed to a sale for £130 million . That figure was significantly higher than the £100 million discussed in earlier negotiations that had fallen through. The Tribunal accepted that this was a life-changing opportunity for the family to realise their investment in P Ltd, which supported the view that the real purpose of the deal was commercial rather than tax-driven. The £130 million price was payable as: £60 million in cash £40 million in deferred loan notes (backed by £40 million deposited in a solicitor’s account as security) an earn out of up to £30 million, linked to future business performance Four days before completion, Mr and Mrs Wilkinson gifted shares to their three daughters. On completion, each daughter exchanged her shares for: £10 million in loan notes, and a small number of shares in the buying company, designed to give each daughter 5% of the voting rights in that company The daughters were also appointed as non-executive directors of a group subsidiary. The aim of structuring the daughters’ interests in this way was to help them qualify for Entrepreneurs’ Relief, which reduces the Capital Gains Tax (CGT ) rate from 20% to 10% on qualifying business disposals. One year and one day later, the daughters redeemed the loan notes, sold their shares back and resigned their directorships. They then claimed the relief on their tax returns. From HMRC’s perspective, that sequence looked deliberately engineered. From the family’s perspective, it was planned and executed to meet the conditions of the relief. HMRC’s challenge was not framed as “you do not meet Entrepreneurs’ Relief.” Instead, it attacked the structure at an earlier stage, arguing that the daughters should not have benefited from a share exchange rule that deferred CGT. Two rules in the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 (TCGA) were central to this. Where shares in one company are exchanged for shares or loan notes in another, Section 135 can treat the exchange as triggering no immediate CGT. Instead of paying tax at the point of exchange, the gain is deferred into the new shares or securities. This is sometimes described informally as “rollover” treatment. Section 137 can block the Section 135 treatment if the exchange is part of arrangements where a main purpose, or one of the main purposes, is avoiding CGT. HMRC argued that the daughters had been brought into the deal purely for tax purposes. The last-minute gift of shares, the special share classes and the directorship appointments were, in HMRC’s view, artificial steps unnecessary for the commercial sale. It was a case of creating a position that met relief conditions and then unwinding it once enough time had passed. HMRC argued Section 137 applied and issued discovery assessments accordingly. The Tribunal found that while the arrangements did involve tax avoidance, that avoidance was not a “main purpose.” The decision turned on several key findings. 1. The “Arrangements” Were the Whole Deal HMRC wanted the Tribunal to focus narrowly on the steps involving the daughters. The Tribunal rejected this. Following earlier case law, including Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC v HMRC, it held that the relevant arrangements were the entire £130 million sale. The tax planning was part of the wider deal, not a standalone scheme, and had to be judged in that context. 2. Tax Mitigation or Avoidance? The family argued they were simply using a relief that Parliament intended to be available, a concept often described as “tax mitigation.” The Tribunal disagreed. It found that the artificial features, such as the daughters’ directorships and the special share structure, went against the commercial grain of the deal and amounted to “tax avoidance.” However, the Tribunal was clear that being labelled as avoidance does not automatically trigger Section 137. The provision applies only if the avoidance is a main purpose of the arrangements as a whole. Here, it was not. 3. Tax Avoidance Was Not a “Main Purpose” The Tribunal concluded that CGT avoidance was not a main purpose of the deal, based on three principal factors: The tax saving was proportionately small. The potential benefit of approximately £3 million represented about 2.5% of the £130 million deal value and around 4% of the family’s £73 million share of the proceeds. In the context of the wider transaction, this was not enough to constitute a main purpose. The sale would have happened anyway. Mr Wilkinson gave evidence that he would have “walked past” the tax saving and completed the sale even if the relief structure could not be achieved. The family was not prepared to risk a life-changing opportunity for a £3 million tax benefit. The minority shareholders had no interest in the planning. The 42% minority bloc had no involvement in or benefit from the Wilkinson family’s tax arrangements and was simply selling on commercial terms, reinforcing the conclusion that the deal was fundamentally commercial. 4. Good Records Made the Difference The Tribunal placed significant weight on contemporaneous documents, including initial deal emails, signed heads of terms and adviser correspondence. Following the approach in Gestmin v Credit Suisse, where courts prefer documentary evidence over oral recollection, it treated the written record as more reliable than witness memories given many years after the event. HMRC asked the Tribunal to draw negative conclusions from the fact that the daughters did not give oral evidence. The Tribunal declined, noting that the daughters had no material role in the negotiations and had delegated decision-making to their father. His evidence, supported by the documentary record, was sufficient to establish the purpose of the arrangements for the family as a whole. This decision illustrates the kinds of factors that can influence whether HMRC’s anti-avoidance arguments succeed. Tax planning within a commercial deal is not automatically a problem. The key question under the law as it stood was whether avoiding tax was a main purpose of the arrangements overall, not simply whether tax planning existed. The wider commercial context, the proportionality of the tax saving and the quality of the documentary record all played a significant role. Business owners should also note the importance of keeping good records at the time of a transaction. Changes made close to completion will attract scrutiny, and the written record created at the time will carry far more weight than recollections years later. The Autumn Budget 2025 introduced significant amendments to the anti-avoidance rules for share exchanges and company reconstructions, with effect from 26 November 2025. Several of the principles that were central to the outcome in Wilkinson are directly affected by these changes. In particular, the scope of what constitutes the relevant “arrangements” has changed. HMRC is no longer required to show that avoidance was a main purpose of the overall transaction. The old “all or nothing” consequence, where rollover relief was lost for every shareholder if the provision was triggered, has been replaced by a power to make targeted, proportionate adjustments. The previous safe harbour for shareholders holding 5% or less has been removed. And the requirement for bona fide commercial reasons has been dropped entirely. These are substantial changes that affect how share exchanges and reorganisations should be approached going forward. For a full explanation of the new rules and their practical implications, see our separate article: New Anti-Avoidance Rules for Share Exchanges and Reorganisations: Are You Prepared? If you are considering a business disposal or share transaction and want to understand the CGT implications under the current rules, our specialist tax advisers can help. Contact us today for a free 15-minute discovery call. Contact US wilkinson-v-hmrc-tax-planning-or-tax-avoidance wilkinson v hmrc tax planning or tax avoidance page Page