Skip to main content
A gavel and a model building on a desk with legal documents.

Purpose of Acquisition v. Purpose of Holding: Tax Relief Requirements for Property Development Interests

Learn how tax relief differs when property interests are acquired versus held, with key requirements affecting developers and investors under UK rules.

In this decision dated 6 October 2025, the Upper Tribunal (UT) overturned key findings of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) regarding tax relief for property development companies, providing significant clarification of the tests for relief from high-rate Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) and Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) in transactions involving options to purchase high-value residential property.

The issues on this appeal concerned whether the FTT erred in law in its approach to determining if the appellant company had acquired and continued to hold the option interest exclusively for development in the course of its property development trade.

The appellant company, a property developer, acquired an option to purchase a residential property whose sum paid was approximately 50% of the property's value. The vendor was the company's director and majority shareholder in its parent, who faced pressing financial difficulties including an overdrawn director's loan account. The option could only be exercised after five years. However, after obtaining planning permission in 2017, market conditions deteriorated. The company exercised the option in 2019 but ultimately sold the property undeveloped in 2020.

Person in a suit reviewing and writing on documents at a desk, illustrating the case brief for Investment and Securities Trust Ltd v HMRC

The FTT found that although the company operated a genuine property development trade, three additional purposes existed for acquiring the option: addressing the director's urgent financial needs, preventing the property's sale to third parties, and providing time to raise development capital. The FTT concluded these purposes meant the option was not acquired "exclusively" for property development, triggering both higher rate SDLT at 15% and ATED charges across multiple annual periods.

The UT upheld the SDLT assessment, clarifying that Paragraph 5(1)(b) Schedule 4A of the Finance Act 2003 requires examining why the chargeable interest itself was acquired, not merely how the underlying land would be used. The unusually high option sum and non-commercial terms evidenced that addressing the director's financial difficulties was a separate, non-qualifying purpose alongside development intentions. While preventing third-party sales and securing time for capital-raising fell within normal property development activities, providing funds to a distressed director did not.

However, the UT allowed the appeal against ATED assessments, establishing that Section 138(1)(b) of the Finance Act 2013 requires separate daily assessment of the purpose for which the interest is held, not why it was initially acquired. The UT held that once the option was granted, the director’s financial need was satisfied and ceased being a purpose for continuing to hold the option. The FTT had erroneously conflated acquisition purpose with holding purpose, failing to recognize that purposes can change over time and must be separately evaluated for each day in annual chargeable periods as the ATED regime requires.

Read the full decision for "Investment and Securities Trust Limited v. HMRC [2025] UKUT 331 (TCC)".

About the author

Jayashree Chapagain is a legal professional with a specialisation in tax, corporate governance and financial regulation. With a background in both business and law, she brings a multidisciplinary approach to her work.

Introducing RentalBux: Our MTD Software for Landlords

Generic software doesn’t understand property businesses and requires manual intervention to meet deadlines. That’s why we developed RentalBux!

  • Built by Property Experts
  • Designed for UK Landlords
  • HMRC Recognised and MTD Compliant
Get Started Today
RentalBux dashboard on a laptop and phone

Confused Where To Start?

Schedule a Free 15-minute discovery call by providing your contact details, mentioning your requirements, and selecting a convenient date for the call.

How our discovery call works:

  • Complete Our Contact Form
  • Discovery Calls Scheduled
  • Receive a Tailored Proposal