Skip to main content
Simran Baniya

Simran Baniya

Simran Baniya, a law graduate with corporate and civil litigation experience, excels in legal analysis, research, and client representation. Transitioning to the corporate sector, she provides comprehensive business solutions and navigates legal compliance. Expertise includes corporate and civil litigation, contract matters, and due diligence.

Published entries

A professional man reviewing documents in an office setting.

10/2/2026

A Complaint Response Is Not a Decision: Mountrail Company Holdings Ltd v HMRC

A Complaint Response Is Not a Decision: Mountrail Company Holdings Ltd v HMRC A Complaint Response Is Not a Decision: Mountrail Company Holdings Ltd v HMRC Facts & Procedural History The Issue The Arguments HMRC’s Case The Appellant’s Case The Tribunal’s Analysis The Penalties: Consequence & Limit Late-Filing Penalties Late-Payment Penalties Conclusion Mountrail Company Holdings Ltd (the “Appellant”) appealed to the First-tier Tribunal against HMRC’s alleged refusal of its claims for relief from the Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) for 2013/14 to 2016/17, and against a number of penalties. HMRC objected that the appeals were out of time. The hearing therefore concerned whether the appeals could proceed at all, a “simple summary” which, as the Tribunal observed, “belies the complexity of the factual and legal issues that arise in this case”. On the central relief issue, HMRC’s argument that the appeal was late failed at an earlier stage. HMRC had never communicated a decision on the relief claims. The only document it could identify was a response from its complaints team. The Tribunal held that “the response to a complaint which sets out the narrative history of the matter cannot be treated as a decision on the validity of the claim”. The Tribunal went further and highly criticised HMRC’s evidence and handling of the matter as "shambolic," ultimately allowing the appeals for eight late filing penalties and three late payment penalties that had been previously cancelled. However, the judge refused permission for a late appeal regarding other 2014/15 penalties, citing a lack of good reason for the significant multi-year delay. UK Property Accountants represented the Appellant before the Tribunal. Drawing on that experience, this note considers the facts that led to that conclusion, the arguments advanced and the Tribunal's reasoning. The penalty appeals are considered more briefly at the end. They illustrate both the practical importance of the decision and its limits. The Appellant is a non-UK company, with a non-UK director, which owns a UK residential property within the scope of ATED. It filed ATED returns for 2013/14 to 2016/17 within the applicable filing deadlines, as HMRC’s complaints team later confirmed, although the tax was not paid on time. HMRC issued six late-payment penalties, three relating to 2013/14 and 2014/15 and three relating to 2015/16 and 2016/17. In August 2018 HMRC demanded £93,027.41. On 15 August 2018 it then warned of winding-up proceedings in respect of £93,102.04, consisting principally of the 2014/15 ATED charge, interest and the three earlier late-payment penalties. In August 2021 the company’s then agents submitted further ATED returns for 2013/14 to 2016/17, claiming relief from ATED for each year. HMRC treated those returns as late and issued eight late-filing penalties totalling £6,400. The agents wrote to HMRC on 24 March 2022 appealing against the penalties. That letter was apparently not received until it was resent on 25 July 2022 with a complaint concerning HMRC’s delay and an ATED1 form requested by HMRC. On 25 August 2022 HMRC referred the matter internally to its Wealthy and Mid-Sized Business Compliance (WMBC) department “for them to formally approve the change from liability to relief”. HMRC upheld the late-filing penalties on 21 September 2022. On 28 September 2022 HMRC’s complaints team responded to the complaint. In recounting the history, it said that the WMBC referral “has been rejected” because the relief returns had been submitted out of time. It also stated that “[t]he letter is not a valid claim for overpayment relief”. The document was, however, framed throughout as a complaint response. It directed the company towards tier 2 of HMRC’s complaints process if it remained dissatisfied. It did not identify any separate communication by WMBC notifying the Appellant of its decision. Further correspondence followed. On 22 December 2022 HMRC wrote that “no further amendments are required in order to claim relief for 2013/14 – 2016/17 as this was covered by the relief returns submitted on 12 August 2021”. In September 2023 the agents wrote asking to put the company’s case before a tribunal. On 10 November 2023 an HMRC officer, signing as “Review Officer”, replied in a letter headed “Appeal against penalties for late filing of ATED Returns”. The officer explained that the company had to appeal to the Tribunal itself and that, because the 30-day deadline had expired, it would need to apply for permission to appeal late. The Appellant notified its appeal to the Tribunal on 12 February 2024. It sought repayment of £392,400; a figure derived from an HMRC schedule originally prepared in connection with the 2018 demand. HMRC’s lateness objection to the relief claims depended on the proposition that HMRC had already refused those claims in 2022, so that the statutory appeal period had expired long before February 2024. The Tribunal therefore had to confront a logically prior issue: had HMRC actually communicated a decision on the relief claims against which the Appellant could appeal? HMRC advanced two principal objections concerning the relief claims. First, it argued that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction because HMRC was entitled to rely on Case A in paragraph 30 of Schedule 33 to the Finance Act 2013. Case A applies where the amount of tax paid is excessive because of “a mistake in a claim” or “a mistake consisting of making, or failing to make, a claim”. Secondly, HMRC argued that it had already refused the claims and that the period for appealing that refusal had expired. When the Tribunal directed HMRC after the hearing to identify the relevant decision, HMRC referred to “a letter dated 22nd August 2022”. No such letter existed. The Tribunal understood HMRC to be referring to the complaint response dated 28 September 2022. HMRC accepted that this letter related to only one of the claims but maintained that the same reasoning applied to them all. The Appellant submitted that the September 2022 complaint response was not a formal decision capable of starting the appeal period. It emphasised that the letter was framed as part of HMRC’s complaints process rather than as an appealable decision. It did not identify itself as a statutory decision, explain a right of appeal to the Tribunal or state a statutory time limit for doing so. That approach was said to be consistent with the observation of the Upper Tribunal in Martland v HMRC [2018] UKUT 178 (TCC) that HMRC’s appealable decisions generally contain a reasonably clear explanation of the relevant appeal rights. The Appellant also relied on HMRC’s later correspondence. In particular, the letter of 22 December 2022 said that no further amendments were required to claim relief because the relief returns already submitted covered the relevant years. The Appellant argued that HMRC’s correspondence was therefore ambiguous and contradictory. Reliance was also placed on Octagon Green Solutions Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKUT 268 (TCC), where the Upper Tribunal took into account the extent to which prejudice relied upon by HMRC was “somewhat self-inflicted” because HMRC’s own communications had been ambiguous. The Appellant’s primary submission was that time began to run, at the earliest, on 10 November 2023. Alternatively, it asked for permission to appeal late, relying on HMRC’s confusing correspondence, continuing engagement with HMRC, and disruption caused by the death of the company’s director and the illness and subsequent death of an adviser. The Tribunal regarded the character of the 28 September 2022 letter as clear. It was a complaint response and referred expressly to HMRC’s two-tier complaints procedure. The letter showed that the question whether relief could be granted had been referred to WMBC. What was missing was evidence that WMBC’s decision had itself been communicated to the taxpayer. The Tribunal stated: “While there has clearly been a significant amount of confusion in this matter over a number of years, it is beholden on HMRC to communicate the decisions it has taken to the taxpayer.” It also observed that HMRC’s inability, even after being given a further opportunity, to identify anything beyond the complaint letter as an example of its decision suggested that clear correspondence was not available. The Tribunal therefore concluded: “There can therefore be no question of lateness of an appeal, since no decision has been issued to the Appellant against which they can bring an appeal.” The point is narrower than the headline suggests. The Tribunal did not hold that a complaint letter can never communicate an appealable decision; it held that a complaint response which merely narrates the internal history cannot be treated as one. Its conclusion depended on the nature of this particular correspondence. The September letter narrated an internal history, including WMBC’s reported rejection of the referral, but there was no evidence that HMRC had communicated WMBC’s substantive decision to the Appellant. The late-filing penalties exposed a separate problem. HMRC had imposed eight penalties on the further returns submitted in 2021. However, the original ATED returns had been filed on time. HMRC’s own complaints correspondence confirmed that position. The Tribunal held that the fact that those original returns were now said by the taxpayer to have been incorrect did not invalidate their original filing. The later penalty notices had therefore been issued on an incorrect basis. Although the hearing had principally concerned whether late appeals should be admitted, the Tribunal decided that it was proportionate and in the interests of justice, consistently with rule 2 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009, to determine the substantive penalty issue without further delay or cost. It allowed the appeals against all eight late-filing penalties , describing HMRC’s presentation of the issue as “nothing short of shambolic.” Note The penalties were imposed under Finance Act 2009, Sch 55. On an appeal against a penalty, para 22(1) provides for the Tribunal to affirm or cancel HMRC’s decision. The Tribunal formally allowed the appeals against the eight penalties. The late-payment penalties show the limits of the decision. HMRC disclosed after the hearing that the three later penalties, relating to 2015/16 and 2016/17, had been cancelled in 2017. HMRC invited the Tribunal to allow the appeals against them. The Tribunal did so and directed HMRC to ensure that appropriate credit was given if amounts relating to those penalties had nevertheless been paid. The three earlier penalties were different. The Tribunal found, on the balance of probabilities, that the relevant penalty notices had been received by the Appellant in 2014. They were therefore decisions against which the company could have appealed at the time. Applying the principles in Martland , the Tribunal regarded a delay measured in years as plainly serious and significant. The explanations relied upon by the Appellant related principally to much later events and did not explain the earlier period of delay. Permission to appeal those penalties out of time was therefore refused. Note The late-payment penalty regime is contained in Finance Act 2009, Sch 56. The Tribunal applied the three-stage approach to late appeals summarised by the Upper Tribunal in Martland v HMRC [2018] UKUT 178 (TCC). HMRC’s confused correspondence in 2022 and 2023 could not undo the consequences of appealable penalty decisions that the Tribunal found had been communicated years earlier. Mountrail is principally a case about communication. An internal HMRC conclusion is not, without more, the same thing as communicating a decision to the taxpayer. On the facts of this case, a complaint letter reporting that an internal referral had been rejected did not establish that HMRC had issued the Appellant with the substantive decision required to found an appeal. That distinction mattered because the late-appeal jurisdiction assumes that there is an appealable decision and an appeal period capable of expiring. Here, in relation to the relief claims, the Tribunal found that there was no communicated decision against which the Appellant could have appealed. The penalty decisions provide a useful contrast. Where an actual penalty decision had been communicated and the appeal period had expired years earlier, later confusion in HMRC’s correspondence did not prevent the Tribunal from applying the ordinary Martland principles. For advisers, the practical lesson is therefore twofold. Before analysing whether an appeal is late, identify precisely the statutory decision against which the appeal is said to lie and the document by which that decision was communicated. But where a genuine appealable decision has already been issued, continuing correspondence with HMRC should not be assumed to suspend or restart the statutory appeal period. UK Property Accountants acted for the Appellant. The parties’ submissions are described as recorded in the decision and in the Appellant’s written submissions to the Tribunal. This note is for general information only and is not advice on any particular case. The decision is a First-tier Tribunal decision and does not bind other tribunals. mountrail-company-holdings-ltd-v-hmrc mountrail company holdings ltd v hmrc page Page

BTR Core Fund JPUT v HMRC: Upper Tribunal clarifies mistake in a claim for SDLT

2/3/2026

BTR Core Fund JPUT v HMRC: Upper Tribunal clarifies ‘mistake in a claim’ for SDLT

BTR Core Fund JPUT v HMRC: Upper Tribunal clarifies ‘mistake in a claim’ for SDLT BTR Core Fund JPUT v HMRC: Upper Tribunal clarifies ‘mistake in a claim’ for SDLT Rule Overpayment Relief Framework Multiple Dwellings Relief Framework First-tier Tribunal Decision Application Practical Implications In a landmark ruling for Stamp Duty Land Tax (“SDLT”) overpayment claims, BTR Core Fund JPUT (“BTR”) secured the return of £3,064,633 in overpaid Stamp Duty Land Tax, a sum HMRC had sought to retain by invoking Case A of Schedule 10, paragraph 34A, Finance Act 2003(“FA2003”). The Upper Tribunal (“UT”) rejected HMRC's position, holding that an error in calculating SDLT liability does not constitute a "mistake in a claim," even where the taxpayer had claimed Multiple Dwellings Relief(“MDR”). BTR had followed HMRC's own published guidance when completing its return for a £98,172,807 plus an overage of £4,600,000 for the leasehold estate Manchester property known as West Tower (“Property”) acquisition, only for that guidance to be corrected after the amendment window had closed. HMRC's attempt to deny relief on the basis that BTR was the author of its own misfortune was roundly dismissed by the UT. The mistake, the Tribunal found, lay in the self-assessment computation, not in the claim itself, and HMRC were accordingly liable to refund the overpayment in full, the excess having arisen from the erroneous application of the higher rates. The legal framework governing this dispute centres on the interaction between two distinct statutory regimes within the Finance Act 2003: the overpayment relief provisions and the Multiple Dwellings Relief provisions. Paragraph 34 of Schedule 10 to FA 2003 provides the statutory basis for recovering SDLT that should not have been paid. It entitles a person who has paid excessive SDLT to claim repayment from HMRC. However, this right is not absolute. Paragraph 34A carves out specific circumstances in which HMRC are not liable to give effect to such a claim. Case A, at paragraph 34A(2)(a), applies where the amount paid was excessive "by reason of a mistake in a claim or election." This exclusion lies at the heart of the present dispute: HMRC contended that BTR's overpayment fell within Case A; BTR argued it did not. The MDR provisions in section 58D and Schedule 6B of FA 2003 establish a two-stage framework. Section 58D (2) governs the procedural act of claiming: MDR must be made in a land transaction return or amendment. Schedule 6B paragraphs 4 and 5 then prescribe the substantive calculation of relief once a valid claim exists. Importantly, Section 76(3) imposes a separate obligation every return must include a self-assessment of tax chargeable, regardless of whether any relief is claimed. BTR's error fell squarely within this self-assessment obligation, not the MDR claim itself. This distinction proved decisive. The Tribunal adopted a purposive approach to construction, following the Supreme Court's guidance in Rossendale as applied by the Court of Appeal in Timothy Watts v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 1615. The phrase "by reason of" imports a causal test: the mistake must be the reason for the overpayment, and that mistake must be located within the claim itself, not merely connected to it. The purpose of Case A, the Tribunal determined, is to prevent taxpayers from circumventing time limits for making or amending claims by using overpayment relief as a backdoor mechanism. It is not intended to bar relief for computational errors in the self-assessment process, even where those errors arise in the context of a relief claim. The FTT dismissed BTR's appeal by the casting vote of the presiding judge. The majority held that the result of the MDR calculation, once entered in the SDLT return, became part of the claim. The FTT reasoned that Schedule 6B provided a self-contained code for MDR, and that a mistake anywhere in that process was necessarily a mistake in the claim. The FTT also considered that allowing overpayment relief would circumvent the statutory time limits for amending returns. The dissenting member disagreed, finding that the statutory structure distinguished between the claim (the declaration in Question 9) and the calculation of liability (Question 14). He would have allowed BTR's appeal on the basis that the mistake was computational, not in the claim itself. BTR acquired the Property for approximately £98,172,807 plus overage. The Property comprised 350 build-to-rent dwellings and unlet commercial premises. BTR submitted an SDLT return claiming MDR, calculating SDLT liability by reference to the higher rates of SDLT in accordance with HMRC's published guidance at the time. It paid £4,702,886 in total. In November 2020, HMRC amended their guidance, accepting that transactions of this nature were not higher rates transactions. By then, BTR's window for amending its return had closed. BTR claimed overpayment relief instead, seeking repayment of £3,064,633. HMRC initially paid, then issued a closure notice refusing relief on the basis that the overpayment arose "by reason of a mistake in a claim." The FTT, by casting vote, agreed with HMRC. BTR appealed. The Upper Tribunal allowed the appeal. The statutory structure draws a clear distinction between making a claim and calculating tax chargeable. BTR's MDR claim was validly made by completing Question 9—ticking "Yes" and entering Code 33. No quantification was required. The error arose at Question 14: BTR applied the higher rates when standard rates should have applied. That was a mistake in the self-assessment calculation under section 76(3), not a mistake in the claim under section 58D (2). The Tribunal rejected HMRC's characterisation of Schedule 6B as a "self-contained code" where any error constitutes a claim error. Paragraph 1(c) explicitly provides that paragraphs 4 and 5 "describe the relief available if a claim is made", language distinguishing the claim from the consequent relief. HMRC's reliance on Prudential [2025] EWCA Civ 166 was misplaced: that case concerned failure to make a claim at all, not computational error where a valid claim existed. The Tribunal also noted, without relying upon it, that HMRC confirmed they would not typically invoke Case A against a taxpayer who made the same rate error without claiming MDR. This concession was consistent with the Tribunal's construction: the error was in the rate applied to the self-assessment, not in the nature or content of any claim. This decision clarifies the boundary between a "mistake in a claim" and a mistake in calculating tax liability. The statutory structure separates the claim (section 58D (2), Question 9) from the calculation of tax chargeable (section 76(3), Question 14). Case A is engaged only where the mistake relates to the act of claiming or electing, not downstream computations. Advisers should distinguish carefully: errors in making or framing a claim may trigger Case A; errors in computing tax chargeable do not. Where a relief requires only a declaration (as MDR does), an error in quantifying the resulting tax due is a self-assessment error, not a claim error. Overpayment relief operates on a separate, longer time limit than return amendments, do not assume Case A precludes relief simply because the amendment window has closed. Of note, BTR did not pursue a legitimate expectation argument despite having followed HMRC guidance that was later withdrawn. This remains a potential alternative ground in future similar cases. btr-core-fund-jput-v-hmrc-upper-tribunal-clarifies-mistake-in-a-claim-for-sdlt btr core fund jput v hmrc upper tribunal clarifies mistake in a claim for sdlt page Page

Unlocking the Benefits of Sale and Leaseback Relief

6/19/2024

Unlocking the Benefits of Sale and Leaseback Relief

Unlocking the Benefits of Sale and Leaseback Relief Unlocking the Benefits of Sale and Leaseback Relief Purpose of Sale and Leaseback Grant of Relief Rates of SDLT Conclusion Need more expert advice on sale and leaseback reliefs? A sale and Leaseback arrangement is when a company sells an asset and then leases it back from the purchaser. In this transaction, the seller becomes the lessee, and the buyer becomes the lessor. Typically, this involves buildings but can also include other large assets. This arrangement allows the seller to continue using the asset while transferring ownership to an investor. A typical example would be where Party A transfers or grants a major interest in land to Part B (the sale). Out of that interest, Party B grants a lease back to Party A (the leaseback). A sale and leaseback agreement allows a seller to release equity to fund another property purchase and help a business in financial difficulty with a quick release of equity. Separating Assets from Operations: When a company wants to separate its assets from its operating business. Retaining ownership of commercial property can be seen as diversifying away from the core business goals. Releasing Equity: To release equity, either to fund the purchase of another property or to reinvest and encourage growth in other areas of the business. Financial Relief: To help a business in financial difficulty that requires a quick release of equity. Continued Use of Assets: When the business wants to continue using a vital asset without owning it, thus improving cash flow or reducing debt. As this transaction is an exchange, both the sale and leaseback parts are chargeable on the greater of: The market value of the interests transferred. The consideration given. Relief ensures that only the transfer of the original freehold interest in the property is chargeable to SDLT (Stamp Duty Land Tax) . This relief applies to a ‘sale and leaseback arrangement’ and fully relieves the leaseback only. The sale remains chargeable and falls within the market value for exchanges. This relief is not automatic and must be claimed by completing the land transaction return. The relief is also available for a transaction involving: The grant of a lease followed by an underlease back or The assignment of a lease in consideration of a leaseback. Multiple sales can be made in return for one leaseback and still qualify for relief. The leaseback transaction is exempt from SDLT if qualifying conditions are met: The sale transaction is wholly or partly in consideration of the leaseback transaction, and the only other consideration for the sale is money or the assumption, satisfaction, or release of a debt. The interest leased back must be an interest out of the original interest. The sale is not a pre-completion transaction under the meaning of pre-completion transactions of contracts as per FA 2003. If both parties are corporate bodies, they must not be members of the same group for the purpose of group relief at the effective date of the leaseback transaction. (While sale and leaseback relief may not be available, the consideration for group relief may be satisfied for both elements of the transaction) The chargeable SDLT rates in respect of land transactions are as follows: Table A (Residential Property) Relevant Consideration SDLT Rates Higher SDLT Rates Up to £250,000 0% 3% £250,001- £925,000 5% 8% £925,001- £1,500,000 10% 13% £1,500,000 + 12% 15% Table A includes an additional 3% surcharge for certain acquisitions of additional properties purchased by companies. If the relevant land includes non-residential property, then the rates in Table B apply. Table B (Non-Residential Property) Relevant Consideration SDLT Rates Up to £150,000 0% £150,001 - £250,000 2% £250,001+ 5% For land transactions entered wholly or partly in consideration of another land transaction, each transaction is taxed separately. Special rules determine the chargeable consideration. Regardless of whether relief for the leaseback is claimed, the chargeable consideration for each leg is determined by the exchange rules. The chargeable consideration for the sale leg depends on whether there was a written agreement at the time of the sale for the leaseback leg to be entered into. A sale and leaseback arrangement can be a strategic financial tool for companies looking to release equity, improve cash flow, or separate their assets from their operating business. It allows businesses to continue using essential assets without the burden of ownership, providing flexibility and potential for reinvestment in other areas. This approach is especially beneficial for companies needing quick financial relief or seeking to align their asset management with their core business goals. By carefully considering the timing and structuring of such transactions, businesses can effectively leverage the advantages of sale and leaseback agreements. Contact us today for efficient and hassle-free assistance. Contact US Grant of Relief - Sale and leaseback relief unlocking-the-benefits-of-sale-and-leaseback-relief unlocking the benefits of sale and leaseback relief page Page

Person in a checked blazer using a calculator over printed documents and charts at a desk

6/11/2024

SDLT: Navigating Sub-sale Relief and Other Transfer of Rights

SDLT: Navigating Sub-sale Relief and Other Transfer of Rights SDLT: Navigating Sub-sale Relief and Other Transfer of Rights Understanding Pre-Completion Transactions Types of Pre-Completion Transactions Types of pre-completion transactions Compliance Procedures What Happens if SDLT Has Already Been Paid, and Then a Novation Occurs? Minimum Consideration Rule SDLT minimum consideration rule for connected parties Conclusion Need expert advice on Sub-sale reliefs and other transfer of rights? In the realm of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) , sub-sale relief, as outlined in Section 45 of the Finance Act 2003 and its associated Schedule 2A, holds considerable legal significance in transactions occurring prior to property sales finalisation. SDLT relief on pre-completion transactions, commonly known as sub-sale relief, is available to the ultimate transferor of such transactions. These statutory provisions, specifically detailed within paragraphs 15-18 of Schedule 2A of the Finance Act 2003, provide crucial relief mechanisms for ultimate transferor of land transactions, offering full relief under specific conditions. To qualify, the transaction must either be an assignment of rights or a sub-sale. Before we delve into the specifics of sub-sale relief, let us first understand the intricacies of the transactions where such relief maybe available and their legal ramifications. Pre-completion transactions occur before the substantial performance or completion of the original contract for property conveyance. Put simply, they involve additional agreements related to property conveyance before the primary contract is finalised. 1. Assignment: This involves the purchaser under the original contract assigning their rights to another party. For instance, if A sells to B, and B then assigns their rights to C, it constitutes an assignment. It's important to note that while rights can be assigned, contractual obligations cannot be transferred. 2. Sub-sale: In a sub-sale, A contracts to sell to B, who then contracts to sell to Party C. True Sub-sale: Here, B can instruct Party A to transfer the property directly to Party C, unless prohibited by the A to B contract. Back-to-Back Sub-sale: B completes the purchase from A and immediately sells to C, often done simultaneously. 3. Novation: Novation occurs when parties to the original contract agree to replace one party with another. This typically involves a tripartite contract, cancelling the original contract and establishing a new one between the original seller and the new buyer. In typical scenarios, except in cases of novation, sub-sale (pre-completion) relief must be sought by the original purchaser, B, either through inclusion in their land transaction return or by submitting an amendment to it. For example, To illustrate the application of these rules to an assignment of rights scenario: Initially, A enters into a sale and purchase agreement with B for land, with a consideration of £1 million to be paid upon completion. Subsequently, B assigns its rights under the contract to C in exchange for a payment of £100,000. C then completes the acquisition by paying A the agreed-upon £1 million. The desired outcome here is that B should file a land transaction return for a transaction with consideration of £1 million, with the inclusion of a claim for full relief. Conversely, C should file a land transaction return reflecting a consideration of £1.1 million, accounting for the additional payment made for the assignment. Novation, however, operates differently within pre-completion transactions. In cases of novation: B does not acquire the property and is not deemed to do so. Consequently, B is exempt from SDLT based on general principles rather than a specific exemption, negating the need for B to submit a return or claim an exemption. A significant advantage of novation arises when B has substantially performed their obligations. In such instances, where the contract between A and B is annulled rather than executed, B becomes eligible to claim a refund of SDLT paid, as outlined in Section 44(9) of the Finance Act 2003. This rule is crucial in pre-completion transactions, especially when the parties are connected or not acting at arm's length. Under this rule, if connected parties are involved, the SDLT liability is based on the higher price payable by the parties. If B and C are connected, or are not acting at arm’s length, then, while B is ordinarily still entitled to his exemption then C may have to pay SDLT based on the price B pays, instead of the price C pays. This applies even if B and C are not related and are dealing fairly with each other. Whether another party, A, is connected or not is irrelevant in this situation. Let's simplify it: A is selling land to B for £1.5 million. Before the deal is done, B decides to sell the land to C for £1.2 million. B and C are siblings. In such circumstances, while B will still be entitled to relief, SDLT for C will be based on the higher price of £1.5 million. SDLT sub-sale relief presents a valuable opportunity for property buyers to lessen their SDLT liability during sub-sale transactions . However, it's crucial to structure transactions correctly to qualify for this relief, particularly by carefully timing substantial performance of a contract. Solicitors and tax advisers should be engaged from the outset to navigate potential pitfalls. Taxpayers must exercise caution when making claims aimed at exploiting sub-sale relief. In the recent years, various schemes have emerged primarily to exploit SDLT sub-sale relief. HMRC has effectively contested these schemes, often resulting in relief being denied or withdrawn. Remember, if an opportunity seems too good to be true, it likely is! Contact us today for efficient and hassle-free assistance. Contact Us Flowchart: a pre-completion transaction is either an assignment or a free-standing transfer; a free-standing transfer is either a sub-sale or a novation; a sub-sale is either a true sub-sale or a back-to-back sub-sale Adviser working out figures on a calculator beside a model house while a client waits across the desk sdlt-navigating-sub-sale-relief-and-other-transfer-of-rights sdlt navigating sub sale relief and other transfer of rights page Page

Abolition of Multiple Dwellings Relief

4/18/2024

Abolition of Multiple Dwelling Relief

Abolition of Multiple Dwelling Relief Abolition of Multiple Dwelling Relief Transitional Period What is Multiple Dwellings Relief? What is Multiple Dwelling Relief? Six or More Rule Multiple Dwelling Relief and Mixed-Use Property Multiple Dwelling Relief and Mixed-Use Property Conclusion There’s a change coming to the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) regime regarding the bulk purchases of dwellings, effective from 1 June 2024. As announced in the Spring Budget 2024, the government will introduce legislation in the Spring Finance Bill 2024 abolishing Multiple Dwellings Relief (MDR) in England and Northern Ireland. There are transitional rules in place whereby the MDR can still be claimed for contracts exchanged on or before 6 March 2024, regardless of when the completion takes place. The purchases that are completed before 1 June 2024, are also likely to benefit from the MDR relief. Multiple Dwellings Relief (MDR) is a provision in the Stamp Duty legislation introduced in 2011 to alleviate the tax burden on the purchasers purchasing multiple residential properties in a single transaction or linked transaction. MDR allowed for a reduced rate of SDLT to be applied to the overall purchase price when multiple residential properties form part of the same transaction. Under MDR, SDLT is calculated based on the average value of a single property in the whole transaction. The total amount of the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) cannot be less than 1% of the value of the properties. Example 1, David is purchasing three Buy-to-Let residential flats in a single transaction. The purchase price for Flat 1 and Flat 2 is £500,000 each, whereas the purchase price for Flat 3 is £800,000. Hence, the total Purchase Price is £1,800,000. Property or Lease Premium or Transfer Value SDLT Rates SDLT Calculation without MDR SDLT Calculation with MDR Up to £250,000 3% £250,000*3% = £7,500 £250,000*3% = £7,500*3 = £22,500 £250,000 to £925,000 8% £675,000*8% = £54,000 £350,000*8% = £28,000*3 = £84,000 £925,000 to £1,500,000 13% £575,000*13% = £74,750 £1,500,000 and above 15% £300,000*15% = £45,000 Total SDLT £181,250 £106,500 By applying the MDR for property worth £1.8m, the savings on SDLT would be £74,750. Six or more residential properties are considered as non-residential purchases. However, a purchaser has a choice either to apply the six or more rule to the transaction and charge according to the non-residential rates or claim MDR. Hence, the buyer can choose the option that will give them the SDLT tax advantage. After the abolition of MDR, purchases of six or more dwellings in a single transaction will be assessed according to the non-residential rates of SDLT. A mixed-use property combines both residential and non-residential elements to the properties. Mixed-use property ranges from a farmhouse with some land let for grazing to fast food shops with flats above. When dealing with mixed-use property, it can be approached in two separate ways: Approach 1: Treat as Non-Residential Property and Pay Non-Residential Property Rates A mixed-use property has non-residential elements. Hence, the purchases of mixed-use properties can be wholly charged to the non-residential rates of SDLT, which are lower than the residential rates. Since mixed-use properties are classified as non-residential, the additional 3% surcharge applicable to residential property would not apply. Approach 2: For the Residential Portion, Claim MDR by Applying the Residential Rates and for the Non-Residential Portion, Pay SDLT At the Appropriate Percentage of Non-residential SDLT Amount. Under this approach, the mixed-use property is divided into residential elements and non-residential elements. The residential portion is then charged SDLT at residential rates. Non-residential elements are calculated as the appropriate percentage of the total non-residential SDLT as summarised from Step 1 to Step 4. Step 1: Non-Residential Property Price Step 2: Total Property Price Step 3: SDLT on Total Property calculated at non-residential rates. Step 4: (Step 1/Step 2)*Step 3 The SDLT is then summed to arrive at the final SDLT figures. Example 2, A person is buying a property which has two flats above the shop. The cost of one flat is £200,000 whereas the cost of another flat is £300,000. The cost of the shop is £200,000. Using Approach 1 The SDLT is calculated by considering the entire purchase as a non-residential portion and applying the non-residential rates. Non-Residential Freehold Property SDLT Rates SDLT Calculation Up to £150,000 0% £150,000*0% = £0 £150,000 to £250,000 2% £100,000*2% = £2,000 £250,000 and above 5% £450,000*5% = £22,500 Total SDLT £24,500 Using Approach 2 The SDLT is calculated by dividing the properties between the residential elements (£500,000) and non-residential elements (£200,000). Flats are residential properties for which residential rates would apply, whereas, for the shop, we would apply steps 1 to 4 to calculate the non-residential SDLT amount. SDLT Calculation for Residential Portion Property or Lease Premium or Transfer Value SDLT Rates SDLT Calculation with MDR Up to £250,000 0% £250,000*0% = £0*2 = £0 (Subject to a Minimum of 1% of £500,000 = £5,000) £250,000 to £925,000 5% £925,000 to £1,500,000 10% £1,500,000 and above 12% Total SDLT £5,000 SDLT Calculation for Non-Residential Portion We will calculate SDLT as follows: Step 1: Non-Residential Property Price = £200,000 Step 2: Total Property Price = £700,000 Step 3: SDLT on Total Property calculated at non-residential rates = £24,500 Step 4: (Step 1/Step 2)*Step 3 = (£200,000/£700,000)*£24,500 = £7,000 Under Approach 2, the SDLT payable would be £5,000 for the residential portion, whereas £7,000 for the non-residential portion, resulting in a total SDLT payable of £12,000. To summarise, the SDLT payable under Approach 1 is £24,500, whereas under Approach 2 it would be £12,000. Hence, Approach 2 is beneficial when MDR is applied. The change to MDR is likely to affect individuals, developers, or investors in the long run. It will only increase the SDLT payable by individuals purchasing two or more dwellings in a single or linked transaction and may affect the affordability of purchasing multiple dwellings. But for now, there is a small window of opportunity to buy the multiple dwellings and avail the SDLT Relief in the form of MDR. What is Multiple Dwelling Relief? Multiple Dwelling Relief and Mixed-Use Property abolishment-of-multiple-dwelling-relief abolishment of multiple dwelling relief page Page