2/14/2025
Structuring your Buy-to-Let Property Portfolio Structuring your Buy-to-Let Property Portfolio Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) for buy-to-let companies Individual Owners Companies Owners Holding the ‘One Property, One Company’ Portfolio Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) on buy-to-let purchases Individual Owners Companies Owners Holding the ‘One Property, One Company’ Portfolio Capital Gains Tax (CGT) Individual Owners Companies Owners Holding the ‘One Property, One Company’ Portfolio Owners holding a one property, one company portfolio Income Tax vs Corporation Tax Other Costs Individual Owners Companies Owners Holding the ‘One Property, One Company’ Portfolio Register of Overseas Entities (ROE) Register of Overseas Entities (ROE) for property-owning companies Comparison of Costs in Different Ownership Structures What Next? Conclusion Need expert advice on Buy-to-Let Property? When investing in property, especially for buy-to-let purposes, it’s important to assess whether owning the property through a company or as an individual is more beneficial. Both structures come with unique advantages and tax considerations that can significantly affect your overall returns. Owning property through a company may offer tax efficiency and greater asset protection, while individual ownership often provides simpler management and different tax rates. However, key factors like your long-term financial goals, expected rental income and potential liabilities – including Corporation Tax , Income Tax, Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED), Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) – must be carefully evaluated. By thoroughly examining both options, you can make an informed decision that maximises profitability and aligns with your investment strategy. Understanding the differences in taxation, income generation and ownership structure is critical to ensuring the success of your buy-to-let investment. In recent years, some firms have pushed the “One Property, One Company” model without fully considering the full scope of tax liabilities. In this article, we explore whether owning property through a company makes sense in every scenario, and whether the “one buy-to-let property per company” approach is truly advantageous, with real-life scenarios. Individual Particulars UK Resident Non-UK Resident ATED Non-relevant Non-relevant SDLT Basic or additional SDLT rates Additional surcharge @ 2% Tax on Income Income Tax @ 20%, 40% and 45% Personal Allowance of £12,570 Income Tax @ 20%, 40% and 45% Personal Allowance of £12,570 available for some non-UK nationals Tax on Capital Gains CGT @ 18% for basic rate band CGT @ 24% for higher and additional rate band CGT allowance of £3,000 (2026/27) CGT @ 18% for basic rate band CGT @ 24% for higher and additional rate band CGT allowance of £3,000 (2026/27) General Administrative Costs Tax return only Tax return only IHT Whatever is in the estate. Depends on long-term UK residence status (replaced domicile from 6 April 2025) Whatever is in the estate. Depends on long-term UK residence status (replaced domicile from 6 April 2025) Register of Overseas Entities Non-relevant Non-relevant Company Particulars UK Company Overseas Company ATED Additional compliance if property price exceeds £500,000 Additional compliance if property price exceeds £500,000 SDLT Additional SDLT rates Additional surcharge @ 2% Tax on Income If profits £50k or less: 19% If profits £250k or more: 25% Tax @ 25% Tax on Capital Gains If profits £50k or less: 19% If profits £250k or more: 25% Tax @ 25% General Administrative Costs Accounts, tax return etc. Accounts, tax return, NRL form etc. IHT More scope for planning using alphabet shares More scope for planning using alphabet shares Register of Overseas Entities Non-relevant Relevant The Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) is a tax regime introduced by the UK government that applies to corporate structures that hold UK residential properties worth more than £500,000. It is an annual charge and applies to ‘corporate bodies’, such as companies or partnerships with a company as a partner. The amount of ATED due is based on the property’s valuation as of the revaluation date, which is the later of either the property acquisition date or 1 April 2022. This 1 April 2022 valuation is used to calculate ATED charges for the chargeable periods from 2023/24 up to and including 2027/28. The property must then be revalued as at 1 April 2027, with the new valuation applying from the 2028/29 chargeable period for the following five years. For the 2026/27 chargeable period (1 April 2026 to 31 March 2027), ATED charges apply as follows: Property Value Annual Charge More than £500,000 up to £1 million £4,600 More than £1 million up to £2 million £9,450 More than £2 million up to £5 million £32,200 More than £5 million up to £10 million £75,450 More than £10 million up to £20 million £151,450 More than £20 million £303,450 Certain reliefs are available for companies engaged in specific types of businesses, such as property rental or property trading. Therefore, companies that own buy-to-let properties are exempt from ATED charges if the rental business is operated on a commercial basis. However, these reliefs no longer apply if individuals related to the company, such as family members or relatives of the shareholders, occupy the property, even if the person pays the market rent on the property. Even if no tax is due, an ATED return must still be filed. Unlike other taxes, ATED works on a forward-looking basis, meaning the return must be submitted by 30 April of the relevant year (a year in advance). For example, the deadline for filing an ATED return for the 2026/27 period (which covers 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2027) was 30 April 2026. Now that we have covered how ATED works, let’s explore how it impacts landlords with portfolios under different ownership structures. Those who hold their buy-to-let properties under individual ownership are not subject to ATED charges or the requirement to file an ATED return, making it simpler for them. Unlike individuals, companies must account for ATED if the property is valued at more than £500,000 at the relevant date. Even where the company claims ATED relief, an ATED return must still be filed. Companies can either file the ATED return themselves or request professional assistance. The professional fees for ATED return filing may go as high as £500 per year. Individuals with the ‘one property, one company’ portfolio have even more to worry about, as the ATED return must be filed for each company. For individuals with a large portfolio, the costs for ATED filing can become significant. It is important to note that a separate return is not required for each property within a company that qualifies for the relief. Furthermore, if family members or relatives of the company’s shareholders occupy the property, the ATED charge will apply for the period of occupation and possibly beyond. This adds another layer of complexity for landlords managing their portfolios through corporate structures. All property transactions taking place in England and Northern Ireland are likely to trigger the imposition of SDLT by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) if the purchase price exceeds £40,000. Therefore, those looking to extend their buy-to-let portfolio must be aware of SDLT liability and the requirement to file an SDLT return. SDLT is charged on the purchase price of the property if the buyers and sellers are individuals, and on the market value at the date of acquisition if at least one of the parties is a company. Regardless of who acquires the property and the SDLT liability, an SDLT return must be filed within 14 days from the date of completion. If any SDLT is due, it must be paid by the same date. Between 31 October 2024 and 31 March 2025, property investors expanding their buy-to-let portfolio were charged SDLT at the following rates: Purchase Price UK Residents Non-UK Residents Up to £250,000 5% 7% £250,001 to £925,000 10% 12% £925,001 to £1.5 million 15% 17% Over £1.5 million 17% 19% From 1 April 2025, the following rates apply (unchanged at 31 October 2026): Purchase Price UK Residents Non-UK Residents Up to £150,000 5% 7% £150,001 to £250,000 7% 9% £250,001 to £925,000 10% 12% £925,001 to £1.5 million 15% 17% Over £1.5 million 17% 19% If a company acquires a buy-to-let property, the SDLT rates remain the same as those applicable to individuals buying additional properties, as shown in the previous section. The non-UK residents’ rates apply to companies that are controlled by non-UK residents. However, companies may have to pay SDLT at 17% on the full market value of the property if the property’s market value exceeds £500,000, except for those that qualify for the exemption from this rule. The conditions for the reliefs from the 17% SDLT rate are similar to the ones applicable for ATED charges, namely those engaged in business activities, like property rental and property trading, amongst other reliefs. Therefore, companies buying a buy-to-let property may not need to pay the flat 17% SDLT rate. The rules apply as above for individuals who hold each property in a separate company. Although not very common, individuals sometimes choose to buy shares in a company to purchase property under its ownership rather than an outright property purchase. When shares are purchased, stamp duty is payable instead of SDLT. Stamp duty is charged at 0.5% of the consideration paid for the shares, unless the value of the consideration is £1,000 or less, in which case stamp duty is not payable. Even though the stamp duty rates are comparatively lower than the SDLT rates, there are other drawbacks to acquiring properties via this method. Want to know more about One Property, One Company? Read our article on ‘ Pros and Cons of a ‘One Property, One Company’ Structure ’. Capital Gains Tax (CGT) is a tax that is charged on the disposal of assets in the UK that have appreciated in value. As with other taxes, the applicable CGT rates and the method of declaring the gains to HMRC vary with the ownership structure of the assets. For individuals selling their buy-to-let property, CGT is charged at 18% for gains within the basic rate band and 24% for those in the higher and additional rate bands. Additionally, a special 60-day rule for filing the CGT return and paying the CGT bill applies to individuals selling a UK residential property. If the seller is a UK resident, the 60-day rule applies only if a UK residential property is sold. However, for non-residents, the rule applies irrespective of the nature of the property being sold if it is in the UK. Additionally, non-UK residents need to file the NRCGT return within 60 days of completion even if a loss is made on the disposal. Unlike individuals, companies selling a property in the UK need not worry about a separate CGT return. Instead, the capital gains become part of the taxable total profits for the year, and tax is payable at the corporation tax rates. If a company with multiple properties in the portfolio sells all its properties in the same tax year, the taxable total profits are likely to exceed £250,000. All the gains, along with other profits for that year, will be charged at 25%, which is 1% higher than the rate that applies to higher and additional rate taxpayers. Where each property is held under a separate company, the rules on CGT are no different from the ones that apply to a company that holds multiple properties. If an individual using the ‘one property, one company’ scheme to hold their buy-to-let portfolio finds a buyer willing to buy the shares instead of the property, the gain is on the shares rather than the property. Since 30 October 2024, gains on shares have been taxed at the same CGT rates as residential property – 18% within the basic rate band and 24% above it. Having said that, it is unlikely to come across such scenarios, given the drawbacks that come with owning a company. Taxation of rental income is where most of the planning around the structuring of the portfolio comes in. There is a considerable difference in the tax rates applicable to individuals and companies, but the downside is that companies are not eligible for personal allowances. Therefore, buy-to-let investors must be very cautious when planning a structure that best works for them. Taxpaying Band Total Income Tax Rates Personal Allowance £0 – £12,570 0% Basic Rate Taxpayer £12,571 – £50,270 20% Higher Rate Taxpayer £50,271 – £125,140 40% Additional Rate Taxpayer Above £125,140 45% Update: From 6 April 2027, rental profits will be taxed at separate property income rates. Finance Act 2026 legislated rates of 22%, 42% and 47%, and the Autumn Budget on 28 October 2026 announced that these will rise to 24%, 44% and 49% (subject to legislation). Finance cost relief will be given at the property basic rate. However, the tax rates are comparatively lower if individuals decide to incorporate the rental property business, as companies pay tax on the rental income at the following rates. Band Total Income Tax Rates Small Profits Rate Up to £50,000 19% Main Rate Above £250,000 25% Marginal relief is available if the profits are between £50,000 and £250,000. If the company is not resident in the UK, it is not eligible for marginal relief, and 25% applies on the total taxable profit. But there are hidden costs in the corporate structure when the profit is eventually extracted from the company. The primary cost for individual owners with a buy-to-let portfolio is the professional fees for filing their personal tax returns. As the income from all properties can be declared in the same tax return, only one tax return is necessary. The professional fees for filing a tax return can be assumed to be £500 per year. Owning a company comes with a huge administrative burden, which could range from preparing and submitting financial accounts to Companies House to filing a corporation tax return (CT600) with HMRC. The administrative burden for landlords holding buy-to-let properties under the ‘one property, one company’ structure is considerably greater. Shareholders of such companies are required to submit financial accounts to Companies House, file a corporation tax return (CT600) with HMRC and submit an ATED return for each individual company. The professional fees for managing each company’s filings can drive up these costs, significantly increasing the overall cost of compliance. The Register of Overseas Entities is a record managed by the UK’s Companies House, a government body responsible for regulating companies. Companies House introduced the “ Registration of Overseas Entity ” requirement in August 2022 as a key part of the government’s strategy to tackle global economic crime. This requirement requires overseas entities that own UK property or land to declare their beneficial owners or managing officers. Unless they have registered with Companies House and received a unique OE number, foreign entities are prohibited from engaging in activities such as purchasing, selling, transferring, leasing or placing a charge on land within the UK. Individual property owners and companies incorporated in the UK need not worry about ROE compliance. However, entities registered overseas and involved in renting or trading a property must be compliant with ROE. Companies that fall under ROE must do the following: Register as an overseas entity with Companies House File an annual update statement every year If the company has rental income, declare the income on a CT600 each year Therefore, a company incorporated overseas but dealing with property in the UK has further costs to consider because of the ROE compliance requirements. Martin, a Swiss national and resident, is an additional rate taxpayer. He is planning to purchase three buy-to-let properties but is unsure about the route he should take, i.e. owning the properties individually or purchasing each property with a separate company. He plans to hold the properties for four years before the sale. Name Martin Domicile Status Switzerland Tax Residency Switzerland Business Activity Property Investment Renting Yes Are the associated persons living in the property? No Married Yes Nationality Swiss Personal Allowance Yes Property income from three properties £120,000 Additionally, the following are the property details: Property Name Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Property Purchase Value 520,000.00 1,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 Assumed Sales Proceeds 590,000.00 1,200,000.00 2,400,000.00 Deemed Gain 70,000.00 200,000.00 400,000.00 Date of Acquisition 04/06/2024 04/06/2024 04/06/2024 Date of Disposal 04/06/2028 04/06/2028 04/06/2028 If he goes down the individual owner route, his total taxes for the four years will be as follows: Buy-to-let portfolio held for four years under individual ownership – tax implications Tax Areas Amount (£) SDLT 382,000.00 Capital Gains Tax 160,080.00 Income tax liability for four years 157,728.00 Professional fees for tax return filing 2,000.00 ATED return filing N/A Total costs £701,808.00 Workings: Capital Gains Tax (CGT) Property Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Total Sales Proceeds 590,000.00 1,200,000.00 2,400,000.00 4,190,000.00 Property Purchase Value 520,000.00 1,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 3,520,000.00 Gains on transfer 70,000.00 200,000.00 400,000.00 670,000.00 Less: Annual Exempt Amount (3,000.00) – – (3,000.00) Taxable gains 67,000.00 200,000.00 400,000.00 667,000.00 Capital gains tax liability (667,000 at 24%) £160,080.00 Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) Band Range SDLT Rate Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Market Value £520,000.00 £1,000,000.00 £2,000,000.00 Up to £250,000 5% £12,500.00 £12,500.00 £12,500.00 £250,001 to £925,000 10% £27,000.00 £67,500.00 £67,500.00 £925,001 to £1,500,000 15% – £11,250.00 £86,250.00 Above £1,500,000 17% – – £85,000.00 SDLT payable £39,500.00 £91,250.00 £251,250.00 SDLT is calculated at the higher rates for additional dwellings plus the 2% non-resident surcharge that applied at the acquisition date (4 June 2024), giving a total of £382,000. On the other hand, if Martin decides to operate his buy-to-let venture via the ‘one property, one company’ scheme, there will be further complications, especially as the profits will need to be extracted from the company, either each year or in the final year of operating the company. When the profit is eventually extracted from a company, the recipients pay tax on the income at either the non-savings or dividend rates. If profit is extracted as salary, the payment will be an allowable expense for corporation tax purposes, but there will be National Insurance contributions. In contrast, paying dividends is not an allowable deduction, but the good news is that no NIC is payable. Therefore, it is generally advisable to extract a salary up to £12,570 and take out the remaining profits as dividends. Assuming that Martin follows this tax-efficient method and that tax rates do not change until 2028, the following is the forecast of Martin’s taxes if he proceeds with the ‘one property, one company’ regime. Buy-to-let portfolio under the ‘one property, one company’ scheme – tax implications Tax Areas Amount (£) SDLT 382,000.00 Capital Gains Tax 167,500.00 Income tax/corporation tax liability 181,214.92 Annual accounts and tax return filing fees 10,200.00 ATED return filing 3,000.00 Total costs 743,914.92 The taxes and other costs are significantly higher when Martin chooses the ‘one property, one company’ scheme rather than owning the properties individually. For four years, the difference is £42,106.92. However, it can go extremely high for those with a larger portfolio who wish to hold the property under their ownership for longer. If Martin were a higher rate taxpayer instead, the tax implications would be as follows: Individual Ownership One Property, One Company Structure Tax Areas Amount (£) Amount (£) SDLT 382,000.00 382,000.00 Capital gains tax 160,080.00 167,500.00 Income tax liability for four years 77,728.00 101,524.92 Professional fees for tax return filing 2,000.00 10,200.00 ATED return filing N/A 3,000.00 Total costs 621,808.00 664,224.92 Savings under individual ownership £42,416.92 If Martin were an additional rate taxpayer and resident in the UK, the tax implications would be as follows: Individual Ownership One Property, One Company Structure Tax Areas Amount (£) Amount (£) SDLT 382,000.00 382,000.00 Capital gains tax 160,080.00 167,500.00 Income tax/corporation tax liability for four years 157,728.00 172,660.72 Professional fees for tax return filing 2,000.00 10,200.00 ATED return filing N/A 3,000.00 Total costs 701,808.00 735,360.72 Savings under individual ownership £33,552.72 Having explored how the ‘one property, one company’ scheme disadvantages investors, it’s time to consider potential solutions. For those already holding property within this structure, minimising future impact may involve exiting the scheme, either by selling the property or de-enveloping. However, this process requires careful planning and is not straightforward. For investors looking to grow their portfolios, there is still time, and it is essential to proceed with caution. They should fully understand the tax implications before committing to the ‘one property, one company’ approach. While various property ownership structures offer potential tax benefits, each comes with its own challenges that can diminish its appeal. The “One Property, One Company” model, for example, often results in high compliance costs, as each company requires separate accounts, tax returns and possible ATED filings, making it administratively burdensome for investors with multiple properties. Traditional corporate structures may provide some tax efficiencies, but extracting profits can lead to additional taxation through income tax and National Insurance. Individual ownership, while simpler, lacks the asset protection and tax planning flexibility of corporate structures. Moreover, restructuring or selling properties can be complex, particularly when dealing with multiple legal entities. Ultimately, while no single structure is perfect, investors must weigh the tax advantages against the administrative burden, compliance costs and long-term flexibility to determine the most suitable approach. Contact us today for efficient and hassle-free assistance. Contact Us Model house beside a tipped-over jar of coins on a table, representing the annual ATED charge Person signing documents next to a wooden model house, representing SDLT on a property purchase Handshake over a property contract with a model house and keys on the table Person completing an online form on a desktop computer next to a globe, representing overseas entity registration structuring-your-buy-to-let-property-portfolio structuring your buy to let property portfolio page Page